Showing posts with label Feminism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Feminism. Show all posts

Thursday, July 16, 2009

Leadership 3: Epistemology

Epistemology is the theory of knowledge. It enables us to figure out what distinguishes justified belief from mere opinion.

I am not a lawyer, and law was probably one of my poorer classes in grad school. However, my impression is that the legal world assumes there is objective truth, and that people can be objective.

As to the latter, women's studies has traditionally asserted that objectivity is bounded, that our perception of facts is linked to our social identities, like race, class and gender. The growing fields of behavioral finance and behavioral economics also assert that our rationality has limits.

Women's studies also teaches that subjectivity is good. Women's voices have too often been silenced, as have the voices associated with other marginalized social identities. Paying more attention to the subjective allows us to understand the worldviews of people we might have marginalized.

Leaders need to aim for a balance of objectivity and subjectivity. It's impossible to be completely objective. It's also unwise to do so - else, you might marginalize someone and tell yourself that you were completely justified to do so.

President Obama said he wanted to appoint a judge with empathy to the U.S. Supreme Court. Judge Sonia Sotomayor, the President's eventual nominee, once said, "I would hope that a wise Latina woman with the richness of her experiences would more often than not reach a better conclusion than a white male who hasn’t lived that life.”

Conservatives have complained vociferously. To be fair, her remark could easily be taken the wrong way. However, in her comments, she has apparently distanced herself somewhat, in this WSJ article:

Judge Sonia Sotomayor, parrying tough Republican questioning, distanced herself from President Barack Obama's comments about judicial empathy, saying, "We don't apply feelings to facts."

Republicans suggested Judge Sotomayor was changing her views to get through her confirmation hearings. They expressed dissatisfaction with her answers on questions such as what she meant when she suggested a "wise Latina" would make better decisions than a white man.

"I do not believe that any ethnic, racial or gender group has an advantage in sound judging," she said.

"Had you been saying that with clarity over the last decade or 15 years, we'd have a lot fewer problems today," said Alabama Sen. Jeff Sessions, the Judiciary Committee's ranking Republican.

Sen. Jon Kyl (R., Ariz.) cited Mr. Obama's comments that in the hardest questions of constitutional law, when text, precedent and other legal tools reach their limits, the rest must be determined by what is in the judge's heart. The senator asked if Judge Sotomayor agreed.

"No, sir, I wouldn't approach the issue of judging the way the president does," she said. "Judges can't rely on what's in their heart...The job of a judge is to apply the law."

She added, "It's not the heart that compels conclusions in cases, it's the law."


Nonetheless, she still connects experience and empathy to sound judging. From the WSJ article:

On the "wise Latina" matter, Judge Sotomayor first said, to laughter in the hearing room, "No words I have ever spoken or written have received so much attention."

She said she had used similar lines for years in lectures to different audiences, particularly women lawyers or "young Latino lawyers and students."

"I was trying to inspire them to believe that their life experiences would enrich the legal system, because different life experiences and backgrounds always do," she said.


And from a New York Times article:

Still, Judge Sotomayor questioned whether achieving impartiality “is possible in all, or even, in most, cases.” She added, “And I wonder whether by ignoring our differences as women or men of color we do a disservice both to the law and society.”

She also approvingly quoted several law professors who said that “to judge is an exercise of power” and that “there is no objective stance but only a series of perspectives.”

“Personal experiences affect the facts that judges choose to see,” she said.

Charles J. Ogletree Jr., a Harvard law professor and an adviser to Mr. Obama, said Judge Sotomayor’s remarks were appropriate. Professor Ogletree said it was “obvious that people’s life experiences will inform their judgments in life as lawyers and judges” because law is more than “a technical exercise,” citing Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr.’s famous aphorism: “The life of the law has not been logic; it has been experience.”


The corollary to her "wise Latina" statement, then, is that a White man could also be an excellent judge if he were truly wise - if he had balanced judicial objectivity with life experience, subjectivity, and empathy to other social or economic groups. Conversely, a person of color or a woman could easily act unwisely by attempting to be solely objective.

Leaders in other fields should similarly attempt to balance objectivity with subjectivity. It will allow them to make wiser decisions.

Friday, June 26, 2009

Series on leadership: A First Lady Who Demands Substance (Washington Post)

During the Clinton efforts to reform healthcare in the US, I remember being a little uncomfortable at how much authority Hillary Clinton was assuming. The US elected Bill, but not Hillary. I recognize that that feeling is an effect of gender roles in society. I also do remember thinking that perhaps Hillary should run for Senate if she wanted a leadership role - at the time I didn't know that there was no Senate seat for DC. In any case, Hillary later ran for Senator, got it, and was nominated to be Secretary of State.

Hillary Clinton and Michelle Obama were accomplished leaders in their own right before their husbands were elected as President. Clinton had several board positions, such as the Children's Defense Fund and Wal-Mart (urk). Obama held a VP of Community and External Affairs position at the University of Chicago Hospitals before her husband's campaign. She previously had several prominent government and non-profit positions.

Of course, now she's in DC. Her role as First Lady brings several expectations that conflict with her professional abilities. No doubt, after her husband leaves office, she will not have trouble finding leadership roles elsewhere. However, her present position constrains her.

What she makes of her office remains to be seen. It is a secondary office to the President's. I would say that she should seek leadership positions outside the White House, but I'm not sure that's really possible - any position she achieves might be seen as nepotism. However, the Washington Post does have a story on how she is aggressively moving to redefine her position.

For weeks, Michelle Obama had been telling her staff and closest confidantes that she wasn't having the impact she wanted. She is a woman of substance, with a background in law, public policy and management, who found herself relegated to role model in chief. The West Wing of the White House -- the fulcrum of power and policy -- had not fully integrated her into its agenda. She wanted more.

So, earlier this month, she changed her chief of staff, and now she's changing her role.

Her new chief of staff, Susan Sher, 61, is a close friend and former boss who the first lady thinks will be more forceful about getting her and her team on the West Wing's radar screen. The first thing Sher said she told senior adviser David Axelrod, whom she has known for years: When I call, "you need to get back to me right away."

...

In the past couple of weeks, Obama has been more vocal about the specifics of the president's health plan, and she will play a substantive role in promoting it. She will soon announce the creation of an advisory board to help military families. And she will be the face of the administration's United We Serve, a summer-long national service program, which she launched on Monday. Even her social events have a message: She let congressional families know that before the annual White House barbecue today, the 500 guests are expected to show up at Fort McNair to stuff camp backpacks with goodies for the children of military personnel.

Obama has also taken stock of her family life, which she has found to be more constrained than she expected. She has concluded that there's really only one road toward some semblance of a private life for them -- and it leads away from the White House.


Her role includes many elements of interacting with the community. The Post reports that she's recruited seasoned, driven professionals for her staff.

At work, Obama runs her office like a business in which she is chief executive. She doesn't want to micromanage, she has made clear; she wants to delegate. Up and down the hall are professional women with whom she has a longtime connection and whom she trusts to execute her vision. Rogers, another friend from Chicago, has an office just a few feet away. Also nearby is Jocelyn Frye, whom Obama met at Harvard Law School and who is the first lady's policy director. A family law advocate and expert on equal opportunity employment law, Frye is also a link to the D.C. community. She grew up in Washington and still lives a few blocks from her parents' house in the Michigan Park area of Northeast. She has pointed the first lady to homeless shelters, soup kitchens and schools.


She's also moving to support the President's agenda, and positioning herself within the Administration to do so.

Every morning, Rogers and Sher attend White House Chief of Staff Rahm Emanuel's 8:15 staff meeting. Johnston, a newcomer to Obama's circle but a White House veteran, and Katie McCormick Lelyveld, the first lady's press secretary, sit in on White House press secretary Robert Gibbs's daily message meeting. As part of the president's domestic policy team, Frye meets with its staff weekly. Senior aides David Medina and Trooper Sanders work on national service and international issues, and Norris remains close to the office in her new job at the Corporation for National and Community Service.

They're all focused on raising the stakes. "It isn't just about hugging," Sher said. "Whatever she talks about will bring press and interest, but it's important that she's not just talking [but] actually moving forward on those issues."


I want to see Michelle Obama assume a role that is commensurate with her skills. The US did not elect Michelle as President or to any other formal leadership position, and it will cause many people discomfort if she crosses a line by assuming authority she has not earned. However, it also does not serve society if we disenfranchise the spouses of our elected leaders.

Thursday, November 08, 2007

Feminists worry about Hillary Clinton

Newsmax.com reports that feminists won't support Hillary just because she's a woman. This seems reasonable. You can read the article yourself if you want, but I'd like to post a section that caught my eye:

But some feminists object to Clinton's decision to stay with her unfaithful husband, former President Bill Clinton, and others argue she fails as a role model by riding his coattails. And while Clinton supports women's issues such as equal pay, abortion rights and family leave, some don't think her stance is strong enough.


I've heard it said that Bill always had a wandering eye. OK, I guess all men do, but Bill's was apparently a bit more wandering than is acceptable. Perhaps Hillary made a political decision to stay married to him. If she is elected President, it will perhaps have been worth it. If she could not get noticed on her own, that reflects poorly on our society.

Thursday, August 23, 2007

Go see Hairspray

If you haven't seen the movie Hairspray, go see it.

I understand that it's maybe a bit less edgy than the original film and/or the musical, and I understand that John Travolta's casting as Edna came under fire because Scientology is allegedy homophobic (it's no worse than Christianity or Islam or Judaism). But, the movie was very well executed. And campy, cheesy, and very funny. And the leading character is a woman; and many of the major ones are women, either biologically or men in drag. :)

Monday, August 13, 2007

Florence Nightingale


Florence Nightingale (May 12, 1820, to Aug 13, 1910) was a pre-feminist, a theologian, a statistician, and a pioneer of nursing. Image: Susan Jackson of Sonoma College, for International Museum of Women














"She was not 'the lady with the lamp.' She was the lady with the brain-one of those rare personalities who reshape the contours of life." Sir Edward T. Cook, biographer, 1913


She was, in fact, born in Florence, Italy, and was named after that city. She was born to a very wealthy family. And in those days, nursing was not a prestigious profession at all, much unlike these days. When she announced her intention to enter nursing, her whole family was angry.

"When very many years ago I planned a future, my one idea was not organizing a hospital but organizing a religion." Florence Nightingale


However, Florence was not just a nurse. She had a vision for religion ... one that she was unable to realize at the time.

"The time is come when women must do something more than the "domestic hearth," which means nursing the infants, keeping a pretty house, having a good dinner and an entertaining party."


These days, nurses care for patients and carry out doctors' orders. Some nurses are nurse practitioners, who perform primary care services and often have the authority to prescribe medications. Some nurses are registered or certified nurse midwives, and they do a job that is probably as old as prostitution. There are indications, by the way, that lay midwives do just fine on uncomplicated births, and the insurance companies should consider cashing in. Giving birth with a midwife is usually more comfortable than with an OB/Gyn. Hospitals are sometimes organized more for the benefit of doctors than patients. Additionally, there are indications that C-sections are overused in hospitals ... that's major abdominal surgery.

The great reformers of the world turn into the great misanthropists, if circumstances or organisation do not permit them to act. Christ, if He had been a woman, might have been nothing but a great complainer. Peace be with the misanthropists! They have made a step in progress; the next will make them great philanthropists; they are divided but by a line.
The next Christ will perhaps be a female Christ. But do we see one woman who looks like a female Christ? or even like "the messenger before" her "face", to go before her and prepare the hearts and minds for her?


Nurses are also trained to look after patients' social needs. Doctors are not, and they do not have time to do so. We need clinical excellence in healthcare, but health is more than just about the body. It is also about the mind and the soul. Nurses social workers, and clergy are in a position to look after the latter two.

I might add, health is not just about the individual, it's also about the community and the nation. Environmental pollution destroys health. A lack of affordable housing destroys health. High inequality arguably leads to high crime, which destroys health.

The US has failed to realize this. Our health system is too oriented around acute care. As the population ages, and the burden of chronic disease increases, our system will be stretched to the breaking point if nothing is done. Other Western countries may not have the same flaws we have here, but they too are unprepared for an increased burden of chronic illnesses. Global South nations whose leaders are corrupt and have not prepared the country well will face death rates from acute causes like war and pollution on one hand, and an increasing burden of chronic diseases on the other. They will really be screwed.

We need reformers like Florence Nightingale to reform our health systems and our religious systems.


Please pray for:

Nurses and other health professionals.

Reformers in religion.

Monday, August 06, 2007

Should men always pay for 1st date, even if they're dating a feminist?

MSN asks, who pays for the first date?


By Kris Frieswick, MSN Money
It was our first date. He was handsome, tall, educated, thoughtful and funny. He had a British accent and a great body. We sipped martinis and nibbled on perfectly seasoned tenderloin in a gourmet restaurant in downtown Boston. To say he was a catch would be an understatement. Yet the deal was not fully sealed until the dinner check came. He reached to pay it without hesitating.

Reader, I married him.

There was, of course, more to it than that. But one of the things that most attracted me to my husband was his boundless generosity when it came to me.

Me -- the feminist, the aggressive professional, the battler of gender inequality wherever it lurks.

Me -- the woman who thinks the man should pay for the first date.

F. Scott Fitzgerald wrote, "The test of a first-rate intelligence is the ability to hold two opposing ideas in the mind at the same time and still retain the ability to function."

I must be a genius. A hypocritical genius.

One of my many sisters in this hypocrisy is Donna Spangler, a former model and author of "How to Get a Rich Man." She says she simply wouldn't go on a second date with a man who didn't pay for the first. "There's something about the strength of a man who pays," says Spangler. "If a guy doesn't pay for you, you're not being treated like you're special. . . . A woman shouldn't gravitate toward that kind of man."

The feminist in me cringes at those words, but, God help me, I agree with her. I have many devoutly feminist friends who agree as well. Some might say that our position on this matter is inconsistent with feminism, but I'm not ready to hand in my NOW card just yet.

Still, I have seen the enemy and she is me -- and Donna, and my friends, and every other woman who is appalled when asked to go Dutch on the first date.

Perhaps we can rationalize that our desire for a man to pay is the modern version of an age-old evolutionary urge. The female of any species gravitates toward a mate who can provide for her and any potential offspring, says Boyce Watkins, a finance professor at Syracuse University and author of "Financial Lovemaking 101."

Prehistorically, man provided food and shelter to show a woman he was interested. Millennia later, that dynamic is re-enacted at Italian restaurants every Saturday night.

"Paying for the first date is one way to show that there is an allocation of valuable resources to your significant other," says Watkins. "And let's face it, I don't care if you're a human or a bear in the woods, no female wants to mate with a wimp who can't provide."

No wonder men are perplexed by the modern woman. We're actually prehistoric hypocritical geniuses.

"A lot of men are confused by gender equality," says Watkins. "They hear a woman is equal to a man, but the minute you try to apply this to dating, you find she doesn't want to go out with you anymore."

It's not only men who are confused. Women can't seem to come to a consensus, either. Struggling to maintain a semblance of integrity, they come up with a compromise: Whoever invites pays.

"It's a host or hostess thing," says Jacqueline Mitchell, a writer for an alumni magazine at Tufts University in Boston. "If you ask someone to your house for dinner, you know you're footing the bill."

But there's just one tiny hitch.

"I'm never going to ask a man out for the first date." Mitchell admits. "It's not that I think it's wrong; I'm just too shy."

Fortunately, it seems, many men want to pay for the first date.

"Men don't want things to be too easy," says April Masini, a dating advice columnist and author of "Date Out of Your League" and other relationship books. "Men are hunters. When it comes to a relationship, the man needs to pursue the relationship. When it comes to romance, it's not the same as the boardroom."

Paying for dinner is a man's way of signaling that the date is romantic, as opposed to platonic, she says. If a woman offers to pay, men feel pursued, and the thrill of the hunt evaporates, making a second date unlikely.

Evolution is only partially to blame. We can point to the usual suspects -- TV, Mom and Dad, and "society," says Dr. Molly Barrow, a relationship expert, psychologist and author of "Matchlines." Thanks to brainwashing from this Terrible Trio, "most men feel that their job and their earning power equates with their self-worth," says Barrow. "Women do not equate their self-worth with their income. They

do equate their self-worth with how their partner treats them."

Put the two together, and guess who's paying for dinner?

"Giving stronger female role models to children will help us break out of this pattern," says Barrow. "Men will eventually disengage from the money equals power equals self-worth thing and as they do that, females will learn to define their own self-worth differently."

Fat chance, says writer Spangler.

"I don't care what the feminists say; a man is a man," she says. "He's got a sex drive and he doesn't value the girl that pays. There are some things that are true, whether you want them to be or not."

Story of my hypocritical life.

[I did recently have a few dates with a fellow feminist, and I did pay for the first date. She kind of ditched me, but I'm pretty sure it wasn't because I treated her to dinner.

Honestly ... I would feel a little uncomfortable going Dutch on the first date. It is just the way that I and billions of men have been conditioned.]

Wednesday, July 04, 2007

Edwina Gateley: Sophia and the Feminine Mystics

Edwina Gateley is a Roman Catholic lay minister. She should be Pope. Here, she writes for Call to Action, USA.

In the beginning there was the Spirit of God. Wisdom. Sophia. Ruah in Hebrew. Co-creator with God in the Hebrew Scriptures. She danced, and was playful, and called the universe into being. The Spirit, working side by side as co-creator with Yahweh. Bringing forth, birthing the earth. Filled with imagination, life, energy. And she was the feminine principle. She was female. In the Hebrew Scriptures, only Moses, Job, David and God are treated in more depth than Sophia, Wisdom. She was such a powerful force in the beginning. But today it seems that Sophia-Feminine-Wisdom is not commonly understood. Our children don't talk about her calling forth new life. Slowly she was edged out of our traditions. Marginalized in favor of the single, male, Yahweh, because Sophia, the Feminine, was too exuberant, too elusive, too ambiguous for our rigid Christian doctrines. She was left to the fringe groups: the school of John, the poet, the artist. She was left to the mystics, who were always a little bit wild. The whole feminine dimension of God's creative power had to be suppressed if we were to put some order and rationale into our Christian doctrine.

Today Sophia, Wisdom, is sneaking back. Little by little, I believe, from a grassroots, deep level, the Spirit of Wisdom is reemerging in our consciousness. She is returning - mostly in women.

Mostly we have seen Sophia in the early feminine mystics. The mystics are God's last resort. Because they are not normal, and have not bought into our rigid Christian doctrine, the mystics have encountered a God who electrifies them, fills them with a wild hope and dream for the human race. For a world which is hungry and tired, God manifests the Divine presence in Sophia through people who are open to the mystical experience. We have to loosen up if we are to experience in our frightened and insecure world God's more wholesome life, linked not only with the masculine Yahweh, but with the feminine Sophia.

Mystics break through with a new vision. Mystics say to the people, 'Look! There is another way.' But in that journey, mystics first hit rock bottom themselves. The experience of mysticism is a salvation experience. The mystic in experiencing God also experiences the incredible loneliness of the darkness in which God moves within us. Mystics come out of turmoil and darkness, and break through to the world with God's message: I am with you in spite of your darkness.

One of those women mystics was Julian of Norwich. She was an Englishwoman, born in 1342, and interestingly, she was nameless. She is called by the name of the church she lived in: she lived in a part of the wall of the Church of St. Julian in the city of Norwich. A nameless woman - like so many women today who struggle.

In her longing for God, Julian wanted to experience the passion of Jesus, the pain and suffering that Jesus had gone through. And poor woman, she got it real bad. She got so sick she was on the brink of death. In that near-death experience God scooped her up and assured her that God was with her and that she would live. It gave her an incredible awareness of God's presence.

The experience of pain and darkness through which we come to conversion belongs to the community. Julian moved from personal piety, from "me and Jesus suffering together for the sins of the world!" She realized that for her to be comforted was a message for the wider world. All will be well, because I nearly died. but I did not die.

Julian lived in a time when there were many troubles: the Peasant Wars, the Hundred Years' Revolution, and the great plague known as the Black Death. The plague wiped out 50 percent of Europe. People would be fine, and twelve hours later they would be dead. There was no medical science to explain it. People were terrified. The only explanation was: God is punishing us. There must be something wrong with us. (The parallel today is AIDS.) Julian went through three episodes of the plague in her lifetime, and survived them all. She came out alive, and began saying, "It's all right. Maybe we have been brought to our knees, but it's all right." She began using terms for God such as Mother and Comforter - to comfort God's people. The only reason this woman could get through to people was that she had herself nearly died. She had been on the journey. She knew what she was talking about.

So also today, women who have been on the journey of disintegration, oppression and pain are the ones who will call forth salvation, and assure people of God's presence.

People who could not diagnose the plague in those days (like AIDS today) felt that they were sinful - and this was endorsed by the Church. The whole development of confession occurred around the same time. Maybe we must appease a God who is angry. Onto the consciousness of a whole people came the sense of fear and guilt - and original sin along with it. We are sinful; we deserve to be punished. The Catholic Church in particular, I believe, has used the whole punishment business to keep us cowed, to keep us down, when our eyes should be vibrant with God's life and Spirit.

The mystics were different. The mystics celebrated and accepted the darkness as a means to salvation and God's light. That was their function. God appeared to Julian and tried to communicate to God's people through her. She said: God is incapable of anger. God is not going to zap you. God just wants us to understand Wisdom. God never promised that we would not suffer, but that we would not be overcome.

God showed Julian two major impediments facing the human race. One is our impatience with suffering, our flight from all pain. In the spiritual journey it is vital to accept pain, to find God's light within the darkness.

The second is despair. We give up hope so easily. Something sucks us down. But the spirit of Sophia breaks through the darkness. We will hit rock bottom. Both individually and as a people, a nation, we will be bowed down, so that we may experience salvation. When we as a people bow ourselves down because we have no more control, the light of faith that is left, the spirit of Sophia that is in the community, will say, 'It's OK. We will raise ourselves up because God is with us.' And maybe then we will truly be a people of God transformed.

As each individual experiences the journey of conversion, so too must the community. The mystics tried to tell us that. We say: The mystics are special, but don't try to be like them. But God says: Yes, you must follow a journey very similar to theirs.

God waits for us. If we are faithful in that journey, even though we hit rock bottom, all will be well.

Monday, June 18, 2007

Mike Nifong disbarred, to leave office next month

Many of you have heard of the alleged rape case at Duke University, involving some lacrosse players and a stripper. Nifong is the prosecutor who filed the charges on highly suspect evidence - the stripper changed her testimony several times. Nifong had witheld DNA evidence from the defence, made inflammatory statements in public about the players and their teammates, and lied to the court.

The fact that an officer of the court lied is only one of the sad things about this case. This also hurts rape victims in general, because here, an alleged rape victim materially changed her testimony in a highly public case; any rape victim who is suspected of inconsistencies in her testimony, or who conceals some facts because she's embarrassed to reveal them, is going to be under suspicion. Additionally, this doesn't do anything good for race relations: the woman in the case was Black, and the players were White. There are still African-Americans who distrust the health care system because of the Tuskeegee study. The Hmong-Americans whose leader was arrested that I profiled earlier believe it was a set-up.

Thursday, April 19, 2007

Supreme Court backs ban on "partial birth" abortion

Yesterday, the Supreme Court, by a 5-4 margin, backed a Federal ban on intact dilation and extraction, a later-term abortion method. The conservative 4 plus Anthony Kennedy, a moderate, voted with the majority. Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, the only woman now serving, wrote in her dissent that the decision was "alarming," and that it "cannot be understood as anything other than an effort to chip away at a right declared again and again by this court." Previously, several states had banned partial birth abortion, not all of them including provisions for use to save the mother's life. Multiple federal courts had found the bans unconstitutional.

Partial birth abortion is better called intact dilation and extraction. It is not used often. The same technique is used to remove a dead fetus (but this would not be banned under any of the state laws). Guttmacher institute reports that in 1996, D&X procedures accounted for only 0.03 to 0.05% of all abortions. The large majority were performed between 20 and 24 weeks gestation. Another procedure is called dilation and evacuation; it involves dismembering the fetus in the womb, and then evacuating the uterus. Most partial birth abortion bans are worded to cover this procedure as well.

It is important to realize that this is a rarely-used procedure. There are other methods of late-term abortion, and abortion in the first and second trimesters is generally legal. However, abortion rights are being eroded gradually, with parental consent laws, South Dakota's complete abortion ban, and now this. Abortion opponents generally intend to reduce abortion access gradually. American opinion is split on the issue, but a complete ban this minute would probably be opposed by a majority.

The Episcopal Church expressed "grave concern" over the use of partial-birth abortion, except in extreme situations. Is is logical to single this procedure out? The other option is inducing birth early; fetuses are generally not or borderline viable at 24 weeks and earlier. There is concern over the fetus experiencing fear and pain in partial birth abortions. And they do basically take the equivalent of a bullet to the brain. It's a quick death, and their nervous systems are rudimentary, but this is a concern. However, fetuses born by induced labor will also experience fear and pain. Should the Episcopal Church not have expressed concern over all late-term abortions? In any case, the Church has also voted to uphold reproductive rights in general; expressing grave concern over one abortion technique is not the same as saying that technique should be banned.

Expressing concern over late-term elective abortions would arguably not be a major infringement on the right to choose. These only account for a small fraction of all abortion cases. A lot of them fall surely into emergency categories, such as mother's or fetus' life in danger, and would be allowable in any case. (It should be noted that currently, most IDX procedures are performed electively, not for medical necessity.)

However, the current political climate is not friendly to the right to choose. Any sort of restriction on the right to choose could be seen as a stepping stone to further restrictions. It would be best if we left the decisions up to the women involved. I think it's also worth remembering that those who support reproductive choice would also rather abortions were used only when medically necessary, not as a means of contraception. That's why they invented the condom and the Pill. State bans on one particular abortion procedure are only one part of the story.

Recent edit: the ban that was found constitutional was a federal ban, not a state ban.

Friday, April 06, 2007

Nancy Pelosi presses womens' issues in Saudi Arabia

[Go, Nancy!]




Instead of wearing the traditional abaya, a long black robe worn by women in Saudi Arabia, Pelosi wore a lavender pantsuit, according to the New York Times. Under Saudi Arabia's strict form of Islam, women do not hold high positions in public office and face restrictions in the workplace.

During the visit, Pelosi commended the king's Mideast peace initiative and his efforts in Somalia and Darfur, Sudan. A member of the Shura Council brought up the difficulty of acquiring visas to the United States after tightened post-Sept. 11, 2001, security precautions.

Pelosi said she did not discuss a statement at last month's Arab Summit by King Abdullah calling the U.S. presence in Iraq "illegitimate."

The stop in Saudi Arabia on Wednesday marks the last leg of the speaker's Middle East trip after traveling to Syria to meet with Syrian President Bashar Assad. President Bush criticized her visit saying it would send mixed signals to Syria.

The Bush administration has rejected direct talks with Syria despite recommendations from the Iraq Study Group for the United States to open a dialogue on Iraq with its regional neighbors.

As House speaker -- and third in line to the presidency -- Pelosi is the highest-ranking official to visit Syria in over two years. She met with Assad for three hours and said she expressed concerns over Syria's connections to Hezbollah and Hamas and insurgents crossing the border into Iraq.

Pelosi also said that Assad was ready to engage in negotiations with Israel. She met with Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert over the weekend in her second visit to Israel since January.

At a dinner in Israel's parliament building, Pelosi told lawmakers that the United States remains united with Israel.

Some media outlets reported that Pelosi was delivering a peace message from Israel to Syria though Israeli officials said their policy toward Syria remains unchanged. Israel blames Syria for supporting Palestinian militants in the West Bank and Gaza.

Tuesday, March 13, 2007

Susan Anthony, died March 13, 1906
"Women, we might as well be dogs baying the moon as petitioners without the right to vote!"

Susan B Anthony was a contemporary of Elizabeth Cady Stanton, Amelia Jenks Bloomer, and Frederick Douglass. She was a suffragette and an abolitionist, and attempted to forge alliances between suffragettes, abolitionists, and labor organizations. Somewhat like Rosa Parks over a century later, she showed up at the 1872 election, cast a ballot, was arrested, and went to trial. She and her lawyer aruged that, as a citizen, she had every right to vote. Supreme Court Justice Ward Hunt essentially instructed the jury to declare her guilty, reading an opinion that he had written before the trial was over. He fined her $100, which she swore never to pay. In a move to preclude her appeal, he ordered that she not be imprisoned until she paid the fine.

http://www.law.umkc.edu/faculty/projects/ftrials/anthony/sbaaccount.html

In the end, Susan Anthony and women worldwide had the last laugh. Wyoming allowed women to vote in 1869, and the 19th Amendment to the US Constitution guaranteed that right to all American women in 1920.

Thursday, March 08, 2007

International Women's Day - God's face with a splash of pink?



Wisdom 6:12-16 (NRSV)
Wisdom is radiant and unfading,
and she is easily discerned by those who love her,
and is found by those who seek her.
She hastens to make herself known to those who desire her.
One who rises early to seek her will have no difficulty,
for she will be found sitting at the gate.
To fix one’s thought on her is perfect understanding,
and one who is vigilant on her account will soon be free from care,
because she goes about seeking those worthy of her,
and she graciously appears to them in their paths,
and meets them in every thought.

Christ Sophia, Icon by Robert Lentz: "Christ Sophia is depicted in this icon in an egg-shaped mandala. The inscription in her halo is Greek for " I am who am," The divine name given Moses at the burning bush on Sinai. The Greek inscriptions in the upper corners are abbreviations for "Jesus Christ," her historical manifestation. She holds the ancient statue called "Venus of Willendorf," and points to herself as if to say, " I am she. Know me more fully.""



Every March 8, many activities are held to celebrate the economic, political, and social achievements of women, and to remember the work that needs to be done.

And on this day, Christians should take a good, hard look in the mirror. For centuries, we have had a male priesthood preaching a male God, or at best a gender-neutral God. But even in the latter case, if a male priesthood is doing the preaching, God ends up being called gender-neutral but acting pretty much like one of the guys.

However, God encompasses and transcends both male and female. The Book of Wisdom is one of the Jewish scriptures. Although they never told us about it in my church growing up, many Christians also consider it part of Scripture. When God is referred to as Wisdom, God is always a She. Wisdom dwells among humankind, seeking to draw us in and teach us Her ways.

It's one thing to ordain women, and to have them as priests, bishops, and teachers in seminaries. It's one thing to change our language, to say, for example, God is my Mother. Those are surface actions. But it's another thing to be able to experience God acting like a woman on a deep level. In the book, Dance of the Dissident Daughter, Sue Monk Kidd argues that masculinity is oriented toward the future, towards heaven, and towards transcendence, while femininity is oriented towards the present, towards earth, and towards immanence. Masculine Christianity orients towards heaven at the expense of earth, towards spirituality at the expense of sensuality. It denigrates earth and sensuality as sinful, broken, and unclean. Sue argues that women have always been, through their experiences of the menstrual cycle and pregnancy, with the rhythms of nature, and that men, by nature, cannot be as in tune with these as women.

The results are that in real life, Roman Catholics hold up celibacy as the ideal. Sex is seen as unclean. And the Roman Catholic Church is one of the greatest enemies of women's health and sexual health. For example, a cardinal once said that money spent on condoms in AIDS should be used on anti-retroviral drugs instead. Another example is my post on Casa Materna, where I mentioned that the RCC in Nicaragua lobbied against abortions and birth control, and left women risking their health to have upwards of ten children each.

I'm not going to spare Protestants either: remember the ex-President elect of the Christian Coalition, who quit after they refused to expand their agenda to include issues aside from sex. Additionally, when Christians evangelized to many indigenous cultures, they took those restrictive sexual mores with them. Many indigenous peoples had greater acceptance of homosexuality and/or gender variance - see my post on Wei-Wa of Zuni for an example. After the Christians came, they turned their backs on that facet of their cultures.

And of course, there is often resistance to feminine images of God. A while back I mentioned that the Diocese of Michigan put up some advertisements on billboards, one of which said "God is my Mother," and that one particular church vehemently denied that God was their mother. Sue Monk Kidd started out in the Southern Baptist Church, which actively taught that women were inferior to men and not worthy of leadership positions in the church. She soon moved to the Episcopal Church, but there too, she faced resistance to acknowledging the wounds that masculine Christianity inflicts on the spirits of women.

“How many times can a woman betray her soul before it gives up and ceases calling to her at all?” Monk Kidd says that women are in desperate need of an awakening to their feminine spirits. Women, and men, are blind to that essential facet of ourselves. I offer an example of what happens if we don't awaken: God has sent us many women prophets. We have often failed to listen. There are those who ignore the evidence that women served as leaders in the early Christian church, and demand that they be excluded from our leadership now. Or sometimes, we listen, but we also pigeonhole: Joan of Arc was a soldier and apparently a successful military leader, but she was a virgin; Saints Clare and Julian were nuns, sworn to celibacy; Mary Magdalene is seen, incorrectly, as a repentant prostitute. If a woman prophet came along, with a message that's inconsistent with our notions of what women do, will we be able to hear?

Many women have turned their backs completely on the Christian tradition, finding that it alienates an essential part of their beings. Similarly, many LGBT folk have done the same, because not only do they find themselves alienated, they also find themselves told that they're going to hell for loving people of the same gender. These losses pain me. I want to share my Jesus with all who will hear, but many have been hurt too much to listen.

And so, I offer this icon of Christ Sophia, of Jesus Christ as a woman, inviting us to know her more closely. This is the face of God, with a splash of pink. Churches have always been guilty of being too slow to change. Right now, we are not worshipping God in Her completeness ... but God does have a way of coming to us in surprising incarnations.

Related posts
http://weiwentg.blogspot.com/2006/12/feast-of-our-lady-of-guadalupe-mary.html
http://weiwentg.blogspot.com/2006/07/feast-of-mary-magdalene-july-22-is.html
http://weiwentg.blogspot.com/2006/07/we-wha-of-zuni-this-is-we-wha-zuni.html

Saturday, December 02, 2006



Four Church Women of El Salvador, and a Condemnation of Sexual Violence

This is in memory of
Sisters Ita Ford and Maura Clarke of Maryknoll
Jean Donovan
Sister Dorothy Kazel, Ursuline Sisters of Cleveland
(The icon is by Anthony Lewis and it's available from Trinity Stores at the link below)
Murdered Dec 2, 1980

And all the victims of rape and other forms of sexual violence, male and female ... some of whom are my friends


Around the time of the Salvadoran civil war, these four women, and other Americans, served as missionaries in El Salvador. Dorothy, for example, taught Salvadorans how to read and write with a program known as CARITAS (caritas means charity in Latin), and empowered them to teach their fellow Salvadorans. The war started in 1977, and Dorothy found she couldn't leave. She worked with refugees, and with mothers who had lost their children. Dorothy said, "I could not leave Salvador, especially now ... I am committed to the persecuted Church here." She and her sisters found that they had to live out God's preferential option for the poor, no matter what it might cost.

On the night of December 2, Dorothy and Jean Donovan went to the airport to pick their fellow missioners up. Ita Ford and Maura Clarke were returning from a Maryknoll sisters in Nicaragua. Five members of the Salvadoran National Guard intercepted them outside of the airport. They were taken to an isolated spot, and were raped and shot at close range. Their naked bodies were found buried in a shallow grave the next morning.

Rape as a weapon of war is only one form of sexual violence. In male-female rape, most rapists are known to their victims. Sexual violence may arise in a married relationship, or in an ordinary dating relationship. It may arise in a casual sexual encounter, where ability to consent is impaired by drunkenness. These latter forms of sexual violence are more common than stranger rapes, and more common than rape in war. They are no less a violation of human dignity.

And men are raped very often in prison. Transgender inmates in male prisons are almost certain to be raped. And shame regarding perceived homosexuality may contribute to underreporting, and many human rights groups allege that prison officials tolerate it because it is used to keep the prison population in line. The rape is one violation of human dignity, and our shame and failure to confront it is another - the same goes for not confronting men raping women.

I previously mentioned on this blog that liberal Christians need a sense of sexual ethics. One facet of those ethics must be that we strongly condemn all forms of sexual violence. In fact, Christians of all stripes ought to condemn sexual violence. And yet, it seems we haven't spoken out enough. Andrew Greeley, writing in the Chicago Sun Times, asks why the Catholic Church has remained silent on the topic of violence against women, despite condemning all sorts of "sins of the flesh" and "sins against life."

Greeley also points out that too many men - including some clergy - need to boss women around to affirm their masculinity. Such men are cowards. Their attitude contributes to a culture which denigrates women, and makes it more acceptable to coerce them. If you are truly brave, you won't be threatened by a woman who is your equal.

Conservative Christians would have us restrict sex to married relationships. For some people, because of their personal and cultural beliefs, it is the right thing to do. It is a choice that liberals ought to respect. However, it will not end violence against women, and it will not end prison rape. Violence against women does not necessarily have to involve forced or coerced sexual intercourse. It can include things such as the actions of the legislature in South Dakota - they completely banned abortion in the state, without exception, and they were using women as a tool for political gain. To my mind, that is an act of violence no less than rape.

We also have to take a good, hard look at the ugly parts of our Scriptures. Some Christians accept their Scriptures as completely infallible - that every word and every passage is completely free from error. There's no easy way to say this - ths is a completely idiotic notion. Many others believe in Biblical inerrancy, which is a limited form in Biblical infallibility - the Bible is correct on issues of faith and practice. This can still be dangerous, because it can still allow rigid interpretations depending on which passages you define as issues of faith or practice. Let's look at the story of Lot, which I have previously mentioned on this blog.

Lot is the only righteous man in Sodom. Male angels come from God to visit him. All the men in Sodom gather outside his house and pound on his door. They want to have sex with the angels - to rape them. Lot refuses - the angels, as guests, are under his protection. He offers to let the city rape his two daughters, who are still virgins. The angels spirit Lot away, and God burns the city to ashes.

99.9% of us would say that God does not condemn violence against women. And yet, Lot put his daughters in grave danger, and faces no punishment. What is going on? If I were God, and I were into the use of fire, there is no way he would have escaped with less than second-degree burns. In fact, in Judges 19, the same thing happens to a Levite and his concubine, only this time, he lets the men of Bethlehem Judah gang-rape the concubine, who dies the next morning. He isn't punished either. And there are other verses in the Bible where rape is treated lightly.

The Bible is a narrative. It is a story about humankind's dynamic response to God. It is the result of a bunch of men (and I don't mean men in the universal sense) coming to know God more and more. It is imperfect, because those men were imperfect. I once heard a story where an Episcopal priest took a Bible, threw it on the ground and stamped his foot on it. He said, "This is just leather, paper, and ink. The word of God is in our hearts, and our minds, and our actions."

I'm not saying to disregard the whole Bible. I'm saying that if you blindly affirm everything in it, you allow others to fall back on it for less savory purposes. When Malcolm X confronted Elijah Muhammad over the latter's shameless infidelity, Muhammad fell back on Biblican figures like David to justify himself. X saw right through Muhammad's flimsy excuses, and eventually they broke their relationship.

If you believe, as I do, that the word of God is in our hearts and minds and actions, then join me in condeming all forms of sexual and relationship violence, and in praying for all victims of such violence, especially Ita, Maura, Jean and Dorothy, killed this day 26 years ago. And let us always oppose all aspects of culture that denigrate women or stand in the way of their equality. Let us in fact take a page from the relationships of same-sex couples, where egalitarianism is often more present.

Amen.


Link to the icon and a brief blurb at Trinity Stores
http://www.trinitystores.com/?detail=617&artist=11
http://www.trinitystores.com/main.php4?&detail=617&artist=11&more=1

Brief bio of Sr Dorothy Kazel
http://www.ursulinesisters.org/dorothy1.htm

Andrew Greeley's article in Chicago Sun Times
http://www.ncdsv.org/images/ChurchNotSpeakingUpforWomen.pdf

Saturday, August 05, 2006

The execution of a 16-year old girl for "crimes against chastity" - Purity vs Justice

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/5217424.stm

In church when I was growing up (it was a Methodist church, very evangelical), we had what we call cell groups, which were small groups that studied the Bible and offered each other support. At more than one meeting, I recall my cell group leader warning us with great passion to resist, at all costs, "homosexual temptations."

Now, I have a confession to make that may startle some. Despite my strong support for gay rights ... I haven't really experienced any homosexual temptations. And so, I nodded my head and resolved to resist such temptations if they ever hit me. Even later on, though, when I had met a lot of really hot gay guys, the heterosexual temptations are always much stronger. So I was always a little uncomfortable with and puzzled by my leader's vehemence.

And when I started questioning my church's teachings on homosexuality, I also wondered, why was not an equal amount of venom directed at social sins, like economic exploitation, environmental degradation, unjust imprisonments and phony trials? Why was the church so concerned about sexual sins? I've never heard Evangelical leaders, for example, say that those who commit multi billion-dollar corporate fraud and cheat investors of their life savings are in danger of hellfire (although it seems one moron priest compared Ken Lay to Jesus and to MLK: http://money.cnn.com/2006/07/12/news/newsmakers/lay.reut/ )

The above link details the story of Atefah Sahaaleh, hanged in a public square in Iran in 2004. Her death sentence was imposed for "crimes against chastity." She was 16, although the newspapers reported that she was 22 and the kangaroo courts that tried her did not determine her age.

To make matters worse, she was raped several times by a 51-year old married man, Ali Darabi. Darabi was investigated by the court, and received 95 lashes. Atefah had a difficult childhood, having to care for her grandparents, and was arrested at age 13, for being alone with a boy. She was arrested several more times, and the locals apparently saw her as a loose woman. The last time, she was arrested by religious police, not secular police, and was tried in a religious court. These courts do not answer to the Iranian parliament, and are inaccessible to human rights campaigners. And in courts that operate under the fundamentalist interpretation of shariah (Islamic law), proving a rape requires 4 adult men or 8 adult women as witnesses. Atefah confessed to the sexual abuse, but Darabi would have been able to say, "she encouraged me," or "she didn't dress modestly," and get off. Atefah realized her case was hopeless, and she shouted at the judge, Haji Rezai, and threw off her veil. This outburst was fatal. Rezai was a head of judiciary. He summarily condemned her to death.

To many Westerners the notion of religious courts with the power to execute people is anathema, but Muslims do not believe in separation of religion and state in the same manner as Westerners do. How they organize their societies to ensure justice for all is their business, not mine, to work out. My business, though, is to condemn people like Rezai who commit such atrocities in the name of God. Such people twist the words of God to suit their own small-minded ends. And generally, when they do so, they focus on issues of purity. We can see such twisting in the actions of the Religious Right in America, trying to outlaw gay marriage and abortion.

But God said, "For I desire mercy, not sacrifice, and the knowledge of God rather than burnt offerings." (Hosea 6:6) Purity codes have their place. For the ancient Israelites, many aspects of their purity code kept them safe from infectious diseases - for example, you were unclean if you came into contact with a dead body. In modern hospitals, secular purity codes (washing, wearing gloves and masks, disinfection) keep us all safe from diseases as well. But purity codes have also been applied to oppress people. The Nazis did this with their race ideology, as did Americans before them. Much of Jesus' mission on earth was speaking out against the Pharisees' misues of the purity codes.

For Atefah Sahaaleh, I pray for eternal rest in the arms of a loving God. For Haji Rezai and others like him, I pray for mercy on the day of judgment, for liberation from power-over, the need to use power to dominate others, and for liberation from the misuse of the codes. And I pray for the safety of all those who find themselves at the wrong end of the purity codes.

Tuesday, August 01, 2006

8 women to be ordained as Roman Catholic priests, 4 as deacons!! Today!!

And it's not the first time. "Rebel" Roman Catholic clergy have been ordaining women as priests and bishops for some time now. In my very limited understanding of Roman Catholic rules of order, since they were ordained by validly ordained bishops, their ordinations are valid. For those women who were validly ordained bishops, the ordinations they perform are valid. At least, all those things are valid until the RCC hierarchy revokes them. I ask your prayers: God, give these brave souls the grace to resist oppression, with strength and love, and without fear and hatred. Amen.

Roman Catholic Womenpriests
Ordination on Three Rivers
July, 2006
There will be an ordination of womenpriests and womendeacons in the Roman Catholic Church on Monday, July 31, 2006. The ordination ceremony is to take place on a chartered boat departing from Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, U.S.A. at 3:00 p.m. (E.D.T.) to sail on the Three Rivers: the Allegheny, the Monongahela and the Ohio.

Bishop Christine Mayr-Lumetzberger of Austria and Bishops Gisela Forster and Patricia Fresen of Germany will officiate.

For further information contact Joan Houk: jhoukmdiv@earthlink.net


http://www.romancatholicwomenpriests.org/news.htm

Friday, July 21, 2006


Feast of Mary Magdalene

July 22 is the feast day of Mary Magdalene. I'm travelling and may not have internet access, so I'm posting this early.

Mary Magdalene is one of the most prominent women in the Bible. There are three Marys in the New Testament. One is Mary Magdalene. Mary of Bethany is Lazarus’ and Martha’s sister. Another Mary is a repentant sinner who anointed Jesus’ feet with perfume; she is generally considered to be a prostitute. Roman Catholics have generally considered all three Marys to be Mary Magdalene. Eastern Orthodox Christians generally consider these to be separate persons. In 591, Pope Gregory delivered a sermon that conflated these women’s identities, and this tradition has continued.

She whom Luke calls the sinful woman, whom John calls Mary, we believe to be the Mary from whom seven devils were ejected according to Mark.



Generally, modern scholars believe that Mary Magdalene was not the repentant prostitute. Some scholars have theorized that she was in fact married to Jesus; it was extremely unusual for a Jewish rabbi to be unmarried, violating the commandment to be fruitful and multiply. The evidence is mainly circumstantial, and there is no way to prove or disprove this contention for a fact.



Mary has often been portrayed with long, uncovered hair, which had very sexual connotations at the time. This may be why Paul commands women to cover their hair in church. Mary is also often portrayed with red hair, and there are sexual stereotypes about redheads. The real Mary was not likely to have had red hair; see the Wikipedia entry for geographical distributions of redheads: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_hair



Jane Schaberg, a prominent feminist theologian, asks us to take a look at our views of Mary. Men in general tend to see women as either virgins or whores. In Christianity, we have the chaste Virgin Mary, who the Roman Catholic Church teaches was a virgin until her bodily assumption into heaven, and we have Mary Magdalene the repentant prostitute. Joan of Arc was a great military leader, but she also died unmarried and very likely still a virgin. We see sex as impure, and accord a special status to virginity. If not that, then chastity is better than nothing.



On the other end of the scale, we have the repentent whore. In Passion of the Christ, Mary Magdalene was played by Monica Bellucci, with her sexy Italian accent and sexy, um, other assets. Schaberg asks us, why not someone like Helen Mirren? Why all these sexualized images of Mary? Can men, or women, take Mary the sex kitten seriously? And for the more modern possibility, that she was Mrs Jesus, does she have to be married to Jesus to be significant? Could she not have been a major player on her own, not owned by a man?

Those views of women have shaped our perception of the Gospels over the centuries. Mary Magdalene was the first person who the risen Christ revealed himself. And yet, because no women were called as apostles, some Christian denominations deny ordination to women. Mary’s historical role could have been much bigger, but we may never know about it, because her role and the roles of other women could have been obscured from history. And so, it is possible that our theories of Mary are inkblot tests that tell us much more about ourselves than about Mary.

How can distorted perceptions of Mary and of women harm us? Two words: Magdalene Laundries. In 1998, an order of nuns in Dublin, Ireland sold some property off to real estate developers. Buried on that property were the remains of 133 women in unmarked graves. They were virtual prisoners of the Catholic Church, sent there for perceived or actual sins of the flesh to live in servitude. The stigma attached to promiscuity around the 1950s was so strong that if they had not become prisoners, they would have become homeless. In those days, the church was the state, so they became prisoners of the church.

CBS broadcast the story, and interviewed some ex-Magdalenes. They essentialy prisoners at hard labor, except that they never knew when they would get out. You could be claimed by a relative willing to take responsibility, but the chances of that were slim. Few were aware of the laundries, and no one knew what went on behind the walls. And unmarried mothers had their children taken away from them, and they were often given up for adoption.

There are two questions here for the Church in Ireland. One, how could you do this? Two, how could you possibly do this in the name of God? There has been no willingness to dialog on this issue, attempts to stonewall compensation claims, and the church took a long time to release the names of those buried in unmarked graves. It is as if they are stonewalling until the media forgets about this. Only Bishop Willie Walsh of Killaloe was willing to talk to CBS and express regret.

Here’s the link to the story: http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2003/08/08/sunday/main567365.shtml
More info at: www.magdalenelaundries.com

So, in view of all that, we have to choose which Mary to follow. I choose Mary the activist. For centuries, Christians have shared painted eggs on Easter Sunday, representing the new life of Christ. One tradition concerning Mary holds that she used her position to gain an invitation to a banquet by Tiberius Caesar. When she met the Emperor, she held a plain egg in her hand, and exclaimed, “Christ is risen!” Caeser laughed, saying that Christ could no more rise from the dead than the egg could turn red. Before he finished speaking, though, the egg turned red, and Mary proclaimed the Gospel to the entire Imperial house.



This icon of Mary by Robert Lentz was commisioned for Grace Cathedral in San Fransisco, to commemorate the consecration of Barbara Harris as a suffragan bishop. This Mary is gazing intently at the viewer, the egg in her hand about to turn bright red. Christianity is as much about the moment before the Resurrection as after it – has God deserted us, is it all really over, did they really kill Jesus? Faith deserts us, leaves us blind. But this Mary has witnessed the Resurrection herself.

Barbara Harris is the first female bishop consecrated in the Episcopal Church, and she is also African-American. Mary’s name is written across the bottom of the icon in Syriac, a dialect of Aramic. Lentz says, “The Gospel comes to us, not from Rome or Greece, but from the deserts of the Middle East. We owe our faith to Semitic Christians like Mary Magdalene. With this debt in mind, we should hear her voice in Palestinian cries for justice in our day.”

And I would like to add: we need more women in church! We need women in Christian history. We need women pioneers like the Philadelphia Eleven, the first eleven women to be ordained (albeit irregularly) in the Episcopal Church, like my friend who is a priest, a woman, a lesbian, a partner and a mother. We need women willing to die for their faith, like Mary Dyer, a Quaker activist executed in Massachusetts when Quakerism was illegal, like the four nuns executed in El Salvador by a death squad for helping refugees fleeing the civil war. We need women who are liberators, like Elizabeth Cady Stanton, promiment feminist critic of religion; like Mother Jones and Dorothy Day, promiment labor activists. Christianity has been limited by the images it presents to us. Come, help us reshape it.