Showing posts with label Saints. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Saints. Show all posts

Monday, September 07, 2009

Cesar Chavez




Cesar Chavez, champion of the poor, saw his family’s home and small farm seized by creditors when he was only 10. He spent his youth as a migrant worker, traveling with his family wherever there were crops to harvest. They shared what little they had with those who had less.

Work in the fields meant long hours of backbreaking tasks and exposure to dangerous pesticides, for half the wages other workers in the United States could expect. Workers had no rights and lived at the mercy of employers. This experience of helplessness and poverty engendered in Cesar a profound thirst for justice. From 1952 until his death, he worked ceaselessly to improve the lot of his people.

After ten years of working in voter registration drives and in challenging police and immigration abuse, he turned his attention to the struggle for justice for migrant workers. Using non-violent tactics and sustained by the deep spirituality of his Catholic Mexican roots, he led the United Farm Workers through seemingly impossible situations. Agribusiness sometimes responded with violence. Several union members were killed. Even the Teamsters tried to sabotage what gains his union made. In spite of all odds, he made the plight of migrants known to the rest of the nation, giving a voice to those who had been forgotten.

Always a poor man, Cesar sometimes had to ask for food for his wife and children from the very workers he was trying to organize. He died on April 23, away from home on union business, after an eight-day water-only fast. An estimated 35 thousand people formed his three-mile-long funeral procession. He was buried as a poor man in a simple pine box. He remains in our midst, however, as a patron of all the poor, but especially of immigrant minorities who suffer solely because they will not watch their families starve. In this icon he carries the Constitution of the United States, for whose guarantees he fought, on behalf of all the oppressed.

-Br Robert Lentz, OFM


Selected verses from Come Labor On, aka the Protestant Work Ethic Song.
Midi file and text from the Oremus Hymnal.

Come, labor on.
The enemy is watching night and day,
to sow the tares, to snatch the seed away;
while we in sleep our duty have forgot,
he slumbered not.

Come, labor on.
The toil is pleasant, the reward is sure,
blessed are those who to the end endure;
how full their joy, how deep their rest shall be,
O Lord, with thee.

Monday, January 19, 2009

Martin Luther King Jr: maybe America must move toward a Democratic Socialism




You can’t talk about solving the economic problem of the Negro without talking about billions of dollars. You can’t talk about ending the slums without first saying profit must be taken out of slums. You’re really tampering and getting on dangerous ground because you are messing with folk then. You are messing with captains of industry… Now this means that we are treading in difficult water, because it really means that we are saying that something is wrong…with capitalism… There must be a better distribution of wealth and maybe America must move toward a Democratic Socialism.


Martin Luther King Jr was, like Jesus, a Communist.

OK, perhaps that's overstating it. For certain, neither socialism nor communism existed as ideologies in Jesus' time. Many of Jesus' sayings (e.g. sell all you have and give it to the poor) lead me to believe He might have endorsed some or many tenets of socialism had He lived today, but it's impossible to say for sure. Martin may have occasionally dealt with Communist Party members, but in the quotation above, he endorses a "move toward" socialism, not communism.

I think, though, that Martin was thinking less in terms of ideologies than of results. Substantive justice, as opposed to procedural justice. Martin saw how the African-Americans of his day were deprived of economic justice. He knew that this undermined the United States because it prevented the country from being a full community.

Ubuntu: a sub-Saharan African concept meaning, roughly, I am because we are.

Marty had a vision of the beloved community. "We are tied together in the single garment of destiny, caught in an inescapable network of mutuality." If one is oppressed, we are all diminished. Ergo, we must work together to accomplish that.

What if Marty's vision never comes to pass? There are many structural difficulties. There is a strong pattern of residential segregation by race and class in the US. The US is also a huge nation that is very sparsely populated in spots. In a global context, there are barriers of culture, language and even larger physical distance.

But that's where faith - trusting in what is unseen - comes in. It takes a long, long time to solve social problems. But for God, a thousand years is as an the blink of an eye, and the blink of an eye is as a thousand years. Marty trusted that God was with him. Americans desperately need to learn about community. And American Christians especially must step up to the plate - Christians are only Christians in community. A church that abdicates its responsibility to the community ceases to be a church.

PS: there was a (Roman Catholic) commenter earlier who said the icon of Marty was an insult to his religion. I put Marty's icon up just for you. In fact, every time I make a post that references Marty, I will put that icon up, just because it offends your religion.

Tuesday, September 09, 2008

Feast of Paul Jones, September 4


Merciful God, who sent your beloved Son to preach peace to Those who are far off and to those who are near: Raise up in this and every land witnesses, who, after the example of your servant Paul Jones, will stand firm in proclaiming the Gospel of the Prince of Peace, our Savior Jesus Christ, who lives and reigns with you and the Holy Spirit, one God, now and for ever.


Paul Jones was the Episcopal Bishop of Utah from 1916 to 1918. You'll note those years coincide with the entry of the United States into World War I.

Those who believe in the Just War Theory commonly point to WWII as one of the examples of a (potentially) just war. However, WWII was linked inextricably to WWI. In fact, WWII was in many ways a continuation of WWI. And World War I was fought for no good reason at all. Europe had been militarizing and the ideology of nationalism was spreading. WWI was started by an assassination in Sarajevo, but if not for that, something else would have done it.

Paul Jones was a pacifist. This conflicted somewhat with the prevailing mood in the United States, as described in an article by The Witness:

Religious support for the war was strong even before the U.S. entered the conflict. In 1916, the Episcopal House of Bishops lauded those who promoted peace, but the bishops made it clear that Christians should be ready to serve the state in time of crisis:

"[America] must expect of every one of her citizens some true form of national service, rendered according to the capacity of each. No one can commute or delegate it; no one can be absolved from it. National preparedness is a clear duty."


Paul Jones, on the other hand, called war "unchristian".

Even if I think war may sometimes be the only possible choice, I agree that war is unchristian. God cannot possibly offer blessings when God's children fight with the intent to kill and conquer. There is always some way other than armed violence. If it seems like there is no alternative to armed conflict, then it just means you missed your chance for peaceful engagement earlier on.

Paul Jones was tried by the House of Bishops and made to resign. There is no other conclusion than that they were drawn in by the nationalist and militaristic mood of the times. And so, Paul's testimony offers some lessons for us today:

ones, who died in 1941, never again served as bishop. But his work for peace continued. He was a founder of the Fellowship of Reconciliation and its secretary for 10 years. He helped found the Episcopal Pacifist Fellowship, now the Episcopal Peace Fellowship. During World War II, he helped resettle Jews and others who fled Nazi Germany, and he argued for greater understanding in relations with Japan.

Jones' legacy today may be more important than before, says David Selzer, EPF chairperson.

"In a time of particularly high patriotism, Bishop Jones was loyal to the sense of seeing the Gospel as the Gospel of peace rather than the Gospel of vengeance."


See, I am sending my messenger to prepare the way before me, and the Lord whom you seek will suddenly come to his temple. The messenger of the covenant in whom you delight—indeed, he is coming, says the Lord of hosts. 2But who can endure the day of his coming, and who can stand when he appears?

For he is like a refiner’s fire and like fullers’ soap; 3he will sit as a refiner and purifier of silver, and he will purify the descendants of Levi and refine them like gold and silver, until they present offerings to the Lord in righteousness.* 4Then the offering of Judah and Jerusalem will be pleasing to the Lord as in the days of old and as in former years.

5 Then I will draw near to you for judgement; I will be swift to bear witness against the sorcerers, against the adulterers, against those who swear falsely, against those who oppress the hired workers in their wages, the widow, and the orphan, against those who thrust aside the alien, and do not fear me, says the Lord of hosts.

Malachi 3:1-5

Thursday, August 14, 2008

Remembering Jonathan Myrick Daniels


The Episcopal Cafe's Daily Reading commemorate's Jonathan Myrick Daniels, an Episcopal seminiarian who was martyred during the Civil Rights struggle in the US. He's on the right in the photo.

Daily Reading for August 14 • Jonathan Myric Daniels, 1965

As soon as [ESCRU’s executive director, the Rev.] John Morris learned of Daniels’s death, he made arrangements for the body to be flown back to Daniels’s home in Keene, New Hampshire, for burial. In place of a formal eulogy at the funeral service, excerpts from Daniels’s theological writings were read aloud to the mourners gathered at St. James’ Church. In one of those selections, he wrote that he had stopped being afraid of death in Alabama, for he realized that “I had truly been baptized into the Lord’s death and Resurrection, that in the only sense that really matters I am already dead, and my life is hid with Christ in God.”

Stokely Carmichael, the SNCC organizer with whom Daniels had worked most closely in Alabama, was deeply upset by the murder and remarked that Daniels had “lived like Christ.” In tears at the interment following the funeral, Carmichael joined hands with other mourners, who softly sang “We Shall Overcome” beside the grave.

At the same time, memorial services were held in many other churches throughout the country, and the slain seminarian received numerous tributes. Frank Mathews expressed shock at what had happened and offered prayers at St. Paul’s. William Stringfellow, who had been one of Daniels’s mentors, called him “an authentic Christian” who had died simply for doing what the gospel demanded; Judith Upham believed his witness demonstrated that “God requires not extraordinary people, but ordinary people with an extraordinary commitment as channels for His grace-full action in the world.”

From Episcopalians and Race: Civil War to Civil Rights by Gardiner H. Shattuck (The University Press of Kentucky, 2000).

Monday, August 04, 2008

Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn dies at 89

The International Herald Tribune has a report on his life.

Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn, whose stubborn, lonely and combative literary struggles gained the force of prophecy as he revealed the heavy afflictions of Soviet Communism in some of the most powerful literary works of the 20th century, died late on Sunday at the age of 89 in Moscow. His son Yermolai said the cause was a heart ailment.

Solzhenitsyn outlived by nearly 17 years the Soviet state and system he had battled through years of imprisonment, ostracism and exile.

Friday, July 04, 2008

Happy 4th of July


Sojourner Truth dedicated her life to the pursuit of freedom for the African-American people through perils and adversity of all kinds. From the bayous of Mississippi through the heart of Michigan, Sojourner Truth, the embodiment of strength, courage and faith in God,
pulled her brothers and sisters toward the pursuit of freedom.
Steven Allen, Battle Creek, MI


Sojourner Truth represents much of what is good about the United States of America. Though she has long passed on, she is still leading her people into the promised land.

There are folks who will say this is more proof that I am aligned with the enemies of America. To those who are invested in their xenophobic, idolatrous nationalism, I say that you are committing a grievous sin. And with the world becoming increasingly multipolar, your hubris will soon become irrelevant.

To the folks like Michelle Obama who are only just becoming proud of their country, I say that pride in your country is no sin. One can be proud of one's country and still change it for the better.

I have no idea what Sojourner Truth's attitudes toward the United States of America were. Perhaps it doesn't matter. Sojourner Truth was an American. She represents the best of what the United States of America can be.

Happy 4th of July.

Tuesday, June 03, 2008

Pope John XXIII



"Let's get lunch." - Attributed to Pope John XXIII just after his election
















Pope John XXIII was born Angela Giuseppe Roncalli, and was sometimes known as Good Pope John. He is a saint in the Roman Church, and Anglicans and Lutherans commemorate him as a reformer of the church.

First, I want to remind folks that Protestantism has developed its own dogma. Sola Scriptura, for example, is just as toxic as the worst Catholic dogmas. As humans are wont to do, Protestants too have fallen into a routine. I suppose the Romans do do dogma a bit more strictly than others, but I don't want us to think that the Romans are all inflexible, and the Protestants aren't.

Still, for many Roman Catholics, Vatican II was indeed a time of great renewal. The Mass could now be celebrated in the vernacular, and ordinary people could understand what was going on. While the Church certainly condemned Communism, and Pope John XXIII excommunicated Fidel Castro, many saw the Church coming to a certain acceptance of some teachings of liberation theology (which stressed Marxist social analyses and was basically Socialist). Vatican II was also seen as promoting increased ecumenical activity. Pope John said that although he wasn't out to change church dogmas, Vatican II would be about preaching Christ's message in light of the changing world.

And that is what Good Pope John offers us: a vision of reform grounded in our core values. Liberal Protestants have always been willing to challenge doctrines that many Christians regard as essential, and challenge is always good.

However, while we must not define ourselves in a way to condemn others, we must hold true to what defines us.

So, while some conservatives may believe in the literal truth of the Scriptures, I prefer to believe that the Scriptures contain everything necessary to salvation. That doesn't mean everything in Scripture is necessary, or that salvation is not to be found elsewhere, but it does mean that Scripture is critical.

And, The Center for Progressive Christianity, in point 1 of its 8 points of Progressive Christianity, maintains that we have found an approach to God through the life and teachings of Jesus. I prefer to believe that for Christians, Jesus is the definitive experience of God.

Christian conservatives in the UK, like Bishop Michael Nazir-Ali, are going on and on about how the UK has lost its core Christian identity, and is allegedly trying to force multiculturalism down everyone's throat. For certain, the UK has become markedly less Christian. It is understandable that Christians might feel a sense of loss. But, instead of wanting a Christian state, can we Christians assert our core sense of Christianity without threatening others?

Globalization and immigration are simple facts of life that Christians must adapt to.

Saturday, May 17, 2008

Celebrating US Supreme Court Justice Thurgood Marshall

This was posted on Daily Episcopalian

Bishop John Bryson Chane writes to his diocese [ed: Episcopal Diocese of Washington]:

Dear Sisters and Brothers in Christ,

As you may remember, our diocese is proposing that the Episcopal Church include civil rights leader and former U.S. Supreme Court Justice Thurgood Marshall on its liturgical calendar. By resolution of the 2006 Diocesan Convention, we recommended that May 17, the anniversary of Marshall’s victory in the landmark Brown v. Board of Education school desegregation case be observed as his feast day.

The 2006 General Convention referred the resolution to the Standing Commission on Liturgy and Music, which, we hope, will bring it forward at the 2009 General Convention, next summer in Anaheim.

One important criterion that the Commission considers is whether there is widespread local observance of a candidate’s proposed feast day. So to strengthen our presentation at the 2009 General Convention and, more importantly, to hold up before our people the Christian witness of Justice Marshall, please plan to observe Saturday May 17 or Sunday May 18 as Thurgood Marshall Day in your parish.

You can learn more about Justice Marshall at edow.org.

In Christ’s Peace Power and Love,
Bishop John Bryson Chane


The Washington Window has written numerous stories on the effort to include Marshall's name in the book of Lesser Feasts and Fasts. (1, 2, 3, 4.) The mainstream media has also paid some note.

Liturgical resources for the feast of Thurgood Marshall, May 17

Propers suggested by the Diocese of Washington. Music suggested by students at Seabury-Western Seminary and St. Augustine’s Church, Washington, D. C.

Collect
Eternal and Ever-Gracious God, you blessed your servant Thurgood with special gifts of grace and courage to understand and speak the truth as it has been revealed to us by Jesus Christ. Grant that by his example we may also know you and seek to realize that we are all your children, brothers and sisters of Jesus Christ, whom you sent to teach us to love one another; who lives and reigns with you and the Holy Spirit, one God for ever and ever. Amen.

Suggested scripture readings
Amos 5:10-15, 21-24
Psalm 34:15-22
I Corinthians 13:1-13
Matthew 23:1-11

Suggested Music
Song of Praise
Christ Has Arisen from Lift Every Voice and Sing (LEVAS) 41

Sequence
Zimbabwe Alleluia

Offertory Hymn
How Great Thou Art LEVAS 60

Memorial Acclamation Sung to the tune of We Shall Overcome:

Jesus Christ has died.
Jesus Christ is risen.
Jesus Christ will come again.
Oh, deep in my heart, I do believe,
Jesus Christ will come again.

Communion Hymn
Just As I Am LEVAS 137

Processional Hymn (and Marshall’s personal favorite)
Mine Eyes Have Seen the Glory LEVAS 226

Monday, March 31, 2008

Dith Pran, Cambodian photojournalist and survivor of the Killing Fields, dies at 65 on Mar 30

A NY Times article profiles Dith Pran, a Cambodian journalist who profiled and survived the Cambodian genocide.

Dith Pran, a photojournalist for The New York Times whose gruesome ordeal in the killing fields of Cambodia was re-created in a 1984 movie that gave him an eminence he tenaciously used to press for his people’s rights, died on Sunday at a hospital in New Brunswick, N.J. He was 65 and lived in Woodbridge, N.J.

The cause was pancreatic cancer, which had spread, said his friend Sydney H. Schanberg.

Mr. Dith saw his country descend into a living hell as he scraped and scrambled to survive the barbarous revolutionary regime of the Khmer Rouge from 1975 to 1979, when as many as two million Cambodians — a third of the population — were killed, experts estimate. Mr. Dith survived through nimbleness, guile and sheer desperation. His credo: Make no move unless there was a 50-50 chance of not being killed.

He had been a journalistic partner of Mr. Schanberg, a Times correspondent assigned to Southeast Asia. He translated, took notes and pictures, and helped Mr. Schanberg maneuver in a fast-changing milieu. With the fall of Phnom Penh in 1975, Mr. Schanberg was forced from the country, and Mr. Dith became a prisoner of the Khmer Rouge, the Cambodian Communists.

Mr. Schanberg wrote about Mr. Dith in newspaper articles and in The New York Times Magazine, in a 1980 cover article titled “The Death and Life of Dith Pran.” (A book by the same title appeared in 1985.) The story became the basis of the movie “The Killing Fields.”

...

He had an emotional reunion with his wife, Ser Moeun Dith, and four children in San Francisco. Though he and his wife later divorced, she was by his bedside in his last weeks, bringing him rice noodles.

Mr. Dith was divorced from his second wife, Kim DePaul.

Mr. Dith is survived by his companion, Bette Parslow; his daughter, Hemkarey; his sons, Titony, Titonath and Titonel; a sister, Samproeuth; six grandchildren; and two stepgrandchildren.

Ms. DePaul now runs the Dith Pran Holocaust Awareness Project, which spreads word about the Cambodian genocide. At his death, Mr. Dith was working to establish another, still-unnamed organization to help Cambodia. In 1997, he published a book of essays by Cambodians who had witnessed the years of terror as children.

Dr. Ngor, the physician turned actor who had himself survived the killing fields, had joined with Mr. Dith in their fight for justice. He was shot to death in 1996 in Los Angeles by a teenage gang member.

“It seems like I lost one hand,” Mr. Dith said of Dr. Ngor’s death.

Mr. Dith nonetheless pushed ahead in his campaign against genocide everywhere.

“One time is too many,” he said in an interview in his last weeks, expressing hope that others would continue his work. “If they can do that for me,” he said, “my spirit will be happy.”

Sunday, March 09, 2008

Harriet Tubman

From Moses of Her People, available here:

Harriet looked around, wondering why so many white ladies were gathered there. I think it was Miss Anthony [probably Susan Anthony] who led her forward, saying:

"Ladies, I am glad to present to you Harriet Tubman, 'the conductor of the Underground Railroad.'"

"Yes, ladies," said Harriet, "I was de conductor ob de Underground Railroad for eight years, an' I can say what mos' conductors can't say—I nebber run my train off de track an' I nebber los' a passenger." The audience laughed and applauded, and Harriet was emboldened to go on and relate portions of her interesting history, which were most kindly received by the assembled ladies.


Robin Morgan, a prominent feminist, attributes this quote to Harriet:

Let a statement by the magnificent Harriet Tubman stand as reply. When asked how she managed to save hundreds of enslaved African Americans via the Underground Railroad during the Civil War, she replied bitterly, "I could have saved thousands-if only I'd been able to convince them they were slaves."


Actually, I think that quote is of uncertain provenance. Ralph Luker, blogging on History News Network, explains:

I might not have caught it, myself, but Melissa Spore's comment sounded right to me. So, I wrote to Kate Clifford Larson, the author of Bound For the Promised Land: Harriet Tubman, Portrait of an American Hero (2004). Larson replies as follows:

I do not think it is an authentic quote. I believe it is from one of the many 20th century fictionalized biographies. It was never recorded at anytime during her lifetime, and interviews with people who knew her after her life never indicated this was something she said. There are many quotes attributed to Tubman that are 20th century creations. This one I believe is particularly peculiar, and in my view, quite racist.

When I contacted Milton Sernett, the author of Harriet Tubman: Myth, Memory, and History (2007), he replied:

I have not found the quotation in question in any of the primary sources that purport to be faithful renditions of Tubman sayings/comments/aphorisms or the like. My impression is that this is a late 20th century quote from a fictionalized account of Tubman's life. ... Whoever wishes to use the dubious quote as a political zinger ought to cite a reliable source.



Nonetheless, many slaves did in fact turn back from the Underground Railroad. Many were worried. Harriet's Wikipedia article, which cites her biographies by Kate Larson and Catherin Clinton, says that she escaped once with her brothers, but they turned back, worried about the dangers ahead. Also, Ben had just become a father.

Harriet, though, was unafraid. She knew she wasn't a slave. She did actually return to her home state, but it was to free other slaves.

She personally helped free hundreds, at least.

People started calling her Moses.

Thanks be to God.

Sunday, February 03, 2008

St. Brigid of Kildare

Feb 1 is the feast day of St. Brigid of Kildare, a famous Irish saint. While history is usually written by the victors, history also does show that Christianity met Pagan culture in Ireland, way back when ... and the cultures seem to have become integrated in a manner strikingly less violent than, say, Christianity plus the Aztecs or the Hawaiians. Brigid was at the center of this fusion of two cultures.

Even today, Celtic Christianity has a distinct flavor. Some Celtic influence can be felt in the Episcopal Church in the US. We are an Anglican church, and our first bishop was ordained by Scottish bishops. The nine St. George's crosses in the top left of the flag represent those nine Scottish bishops.

One of the legends around Brigid is that she was transported back in time to be a midwife at the time of Jesus' birth.

I might catch some flak for linking this site, but Goddess Gift has a page on Brigid.

Monday, December 10, 2007

Azucena Villaflor, disappeared on or about Dec 10, 1977: Reflection for Advent 2



Advent is about hope and expectation and waiting. The season also has strong ties with eschatology, the part of theology concerned with death, judgment, and the final destiny of the soul and humankind. The term derives from the Greek eskhatos, meaning "last."

December 10 is also International Human Rights Day, the date on which the Universal Declaration of Human Rights was signed in 1948. It was a time when nations were determined that the horrors of WWII would never again occur. The General Assembly said that respect for human rights "is the foundation of freedom, justice and peace in the world."


From Wikipedia:
A forced disappearance occurs when an organization forces a person to vanish from public view, either by murder or by simple sequestration. The victim is first kidnapped, then illegally detained in concentration camps, often tortured, and finally executed and the corpse hidden. In Spanish and Portuguese, "disappeared people" are called desaparecidos, a term which specifically refers to the mostly South American victims of state terrorism during the 1970s and the 1980s, in particular concerning Operation Condor.

According to the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court, which entered into force on July 1, 2002, when committed as part of a widespread or systematic attack directed against any civilian population, "forced disappearances" qualify as a crime against humanity, which thus cannot be subject to statute of limitation.


In Argentina, the Dirty War, or Guerra Sucia, lasted form 1976 to 1983. It was not a war against an external enemy, or a civil war in the strict sense. The political history of Argentina is complicated and I do not fully understand it. But it is fairly clear that the Dirty War was a state-sponsored campaign of violence against perceived Argentinian "subversives". Here, "subversives" seems to include trade unionists, socialists, communists, and anyone perceived to be affiliated. There is evidence that because of the fear of Communism, the United States assisted or at least condoned the violent acts of the Argentine military in its own and other Latin American countries.

Estimates by human rights groups place the total casualties in the Dirty War at 30,000. A report conducted by Argentine security forces in mid 1978 and later published estimates that up to 22,000 people had been killed or disappeared by that time.

The country later reverted to civilian democratic rule, but the war criminals were able to manipulate the legal system to escape prosecution. Often, when pregnant women were abducted, they were allowed to give birth, and then they were murdered. "Subversives breed subversives," so their children were often given to military families. These things have all left a scar on the Argentine psyche.


On April 30, 1977, Azucena Villaflor and 13 other women, whose names are listed below, started marching on the Plaza de Mayo, in front of the Casa Rosada, the presidential palace. Azucena's son Nestor, and his wife, Raquel Mangin, had been disappeared. They wore white scarves, symbolizing the dove of peace, and these became the mothers' symbol. They also wore rose buds - a white one if they knew their child was alive, a red one for those who were dead. They had asked the Ministry of the Interior, the church, the police, the military, but there was no acknowledgment that their children were even missing. And the not knowing itself was part of the terror.

The Mothers started to know each other while knocking on those doors and one evening in April of 1977, while they were waiting for a priest at the Stella Maris Church, one of them, Azucena Villaflor de Devicenti, said: "If we do this on our own, we will not get anything. Why don't we go to the Plaza de Mayo and when we become a large group, Videla (then president) will have to meet with us ... "Azucena Devicenti chose the Plaza de Mayo as the meeting place because it is located across the street from the Government House (Pink House) and for being a historical and traditional place for demonstrations.
From the Easy Buenos Aires City website.

Azucena Villaflor herself was disappeared on Dec 10, 1977, which was also International Human Rights Day. The Mothers had published a newspaper advertisement with the names of their disappeared children. She was abducted at night by soldiers. She was probably tortured, as were many of the disappeared. Her body was identified in 2005 by the Argentine Forensic Anthropology Team, which was created to locate and identify the bodies of the disappeared. Her skeleton displayed the forensic evidence of a large impact, and she had likely been drugged, bound, and thrown out of an airplane over water, which was a common way of killing someone so that the body could not be found. These flights were known as vuelos de las muerte, or death flights.

Azucena's remains were cremated and buried at the foot of the May Pyramid on the Plaza de Mayo. The Abuelas (Grandmothers) of the Plaza de Mayo continued the mission of the Mothers, establishing a genetic database to help identify children who had been abducted and given to military families (some were adopted internationally in good faith on the adoptive parents' parts). 56 children were located, 7 of whom died. 31 are with their biological parents, and 13 are being raised jointly (the good faith adoptions). Many of the military adoptive parents managed to escape justice.

However, when one of the first parents to be prosecuted said that the child was better off with him, because he had not harmed her and that to remove her would be far more traumatic to her, the Supreme Court of Argentina disagreed. They ruled that the murders, disappearances and abductions were now public. Paula, the child, would soon learn. And besides, she was living with the man who murdered her parents. Mary-Claire King, an American geneticist involved with the Grandmothers and in genetically testing children, details the story of the abductions, the setting up of test procedures, and the fight to prosecute.



I consider human rights to be essential to the complete development of the human race. Those leaders who fail to endorse human rights have something to hide.

However, it's very easy to advocate for human rights from behind a desk - or from a blog. Azucena Villaflor was on the front lines of human rights. She surely knew or suspected that she was placing her life in danger. No one has greater love than this, to lay down one’s life for one’s friends. Azucena stepped out in love and faith for her son and her daughter in law. Right now, human rights are supported by a body of international law in its infancy, by uncertain national laws ... and by hope, and faith, and love.

In this Lentz icon, Mary is dressed as one of the Mothers. The Mothers would hold photographs of their children, and would wear rosebuds: white if they hoped their child was alive, red if they knew their child was dead. As the practice of disappearance spread to other Latin American countries, so did the practice of the Mothers. In this icon, Mary has no photograph of her Son, only His crown of thorns. The white hand print in the bottom left is the blanco mano, the emblem of Salvadoran death squads. Lentz' icon of Oscar Romero is similarly defaced by the presence of military helicopters.

Whenever someone is murdered, or tortured, or left in poverty, or discriminated against, God's image is defaced. But God is found in the faces of those victims of torture and disappearance, and whenever we stand up for human rights, we stand up for God. We Christians cannot stand by when human rights are violated. If Azucena Villaflor had the faith to call her murderous government to account in the Plaza del Mayo, we can have that faith also.


For Azucena Villaflor and the other Mothers of the Plaza del Mayo:

Berta Braverman

Haydée García Buelas

María Adela Gard de Antokoletz

Julia Gard, María Mercedes Gard

Cándida Gard

Delicia González

Pepa Noia

Mirta Baravalle

Kety Neuhaus

Raquel Arcushin

Sra. De Caim

Sunday, December 02, 2007

Kamehameha and Emma: Reflection for Advent 1



Indigenous peoples and individuals are free and equal to all other peoples and
individuals and have the right to be free from any kind of discrimination, in the
exercise of their rights, in particular that based on their indigenous origin or
identity.
Article 2, Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples






(Note: I edited this on 12/3, adding some last-minute updates.)
Do you know what it's like for Indigenous people to have one of their own numbered among the saints?

Tonight, we observe the feast of Kamehameha IV and Emma. Kamehameha was the fourth king in the Kamehameha dynasty, founded about 1810. Kamehameha and Emma were Anglican by birth, but Christianity had come to Hawaii not long before either was born. Christianity started out nearly 2,000 years ago as a small religious cult, and now has over 2 billion followers. Through millennia, Christians have held on to their beliefs in the face of torture and death. They have also evangelized to every corner of the earth. We would not be here today if not for evangelism.

But, even evangelism has a dark side.

In 1778, Captain James Cook of England made the first European contact with the Hawaiian Islands. Soon afterwards, Western merchants came to buy sandalwood, which was abundant on Hawaii and greatly in demand in China. They brought the Hawaiian natives Bibles, guns, and rum.

Kamehameha the Great, the founder of the Kamehameha dynasty and the grandfather of Kamehameha IV, organized the commoners into a labor force to go up the mountain, cut sandalwood, and bring it to the harbor, in addition to their usual subsistence farming. Sandalwood nearly became extinct, and many commoners died from disease, and malnutrition. Meanwhile, the king used the force of the arms he bought from the traders to unite the Hawaiian Islands. He also bought Western luxury goods on credit, driving the island into debt.


Indigenous peoples, in exercising their right to self-determination, have the
right to autonomy or self-government in matters relating to their internal and local
affairs, as well as ways and means for financing their autonomous functions.
Article 4, Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples





Kamehameha I died in 1819, by which time the island’s population had been halved, to 150,000, from smallpox and other diseases. Christian missionaries started to arrive on the island in 1820. They established a written Hawaiian language, and taught the Hawaiians to read and write. To be fair, many missionaries were concerned with the welfare of the Hawaiian people, who were often being exploited by the merchants, and who suffered from high rates of alcoholism. The missionaries tried to help the Hawaiians start their own industries. And they tried to defend the Hawaiians against exploitation by the traders.

But Christian missionaries were also one of the forces of 19th century colonialism. They tried to impose their standards of modesty, banning the Hawaiians from dancing the hula. They prohibited working on the Sabbath, which interfered with native agricultural production. Many missionaries eventually became advisors to the monarchy. They and many chiefs advised King Kamehameha III to proclaim the Great Mahele, or division, in 1848. The missionaries thought the old system of land distribution was backwards and kept the people in poverty, and they did want to empower the people. The Mahele theoretically allowed commoners to claim land they worked on. However, few commoners were literate enough to understand the declaration, and the immediate result was further centralization of ownership with Hawaiian chiefs.

And in 1850, the law was amended to allow foreign ownership. Perhaps unsurprisingly, by 1890, 75% of all privately owned land was owned by foreign businesses, and much of it was devoted to sugar cultivation. Eventually, five former missionary families came to own the sugar industry. They dominated many other aspects of Hawaiian industry, and came to hold much political power as well. The Big Five sugar producers got the most fertile land, and diverted much of Hawaii’s limited fresh water for refining sugar.

Additionally, Kamehameha III saw the native Hawaiian population halved again, to about 75,000, from a smallpox epidemic. He survived two coup attempts by Westerners, and died in 1855.


1. Indigenous individuals have the rights to life, physical and mental
integrity, liberty and security of person.
2. Indigenous peoples have the collective right to live in freedom, peace
and security as distinct peoples and shall not be subjected to any act of genocide or
any other act of violence, including forcibly removing children of the group to
another group.
Article 7, Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples



And so, Kamehameha IV became king when things were bad and getting worse. He was the nephew and adopted son of Kamehameha III. Born in 1834, and educated by Anglican missionaries, he ascended to the throne in 1855, at age 20.

Queen Emma was born in 1836, and was the granddaughter of John Young, a friend and military advisor to Kamehameha the Great. She married Kamehameha IV in 1856, and they had one son, Albert.

Beginning at least with King Kamehameha I, the people were accustomed to royalty who ruled with pomp and power and lived in luxury. In contrast, Emma encouraged her husband to create public hospitals and long-term care facilities, to care for a population being decimated by foreign diseases. The legislature denied them funding, but they went around the island with a notebook, soliciting funds from rich and poor alike. The Queen’s Medical Center in Honululu was the fruit of this campaign, and it still stands today.

In 1860, Kamehameha and Emma petitioned the Church of England to help them establish an Anglican church in Hawaii. The Church sent two priests and a bishop, and the king and queen were confirmed in 1862.

But in 1863, Albert died, at age 4. Kamehameha felt he was responsible, and he was already in ailing health. At the funeral, he preached a sermon that expressed a deep, profound faith, but it seemed that he had lost the will to live. He died without an heir at age 29, on November 30, 1863. Emma declined to rule, retreating to focus on good works. I don’t think it’s a stretch to suggest that both of them were in despair at having failed their people.

Good works alone could not save Hawaii. Kamehameha’s brother succeeded him, but also died without a successor, ending their dynasty. Hawaii then had three elected monarchs. Kalakaua, the second elected monarch, was forced by a militia allied with descendants of the missionaries to sign a document now called the Bayonet Constitution. The Constitution denied the vote to many native Hawaiians and stripped Kalakaua of his executive power. The Constitution’s author was Lorrin Thurston, the Interior Minister, a child of missionaries, and a powerful businessman. Lili’uokalani, Kalakaua’s sister and successor, tried to abrogate the Bayonet Constitution and draft a new one. She was deposed when John Stevens, the U.S. Department of State Minister, called in the marines, allegedly to protect American civilians. Later, as you know, Hawaii was annexed to the US.

1. Indigenous peoples have the right to manifest, practice, develop and
teach their spiritual and religious traditions, customs and ceremonies; the right to
maintain, protect, and have access in privacy to their religious and cultural sites; the
right to the use and control of their ceremonial objects; and the right to the
repatriation of their human remains.
Article 12 part 1, Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples


Wikipedia defines colonialism as the “extension of a nation’s sovereignty over territory beyond its borders by the establishment of either settler colonies or administrative dependencies in which Indigenous populations are directly ruled or displaced.” Colonialism necessarily entails oppression: establishing political, physical and psychic dominion over Indigenous people. And often, they internalize that oppression, and perpetuate it on others.

Jesus said in tonight’s Gospel, what you did to the least of these, you did to me. He said elsewhere, sell all you have, give to the poor, and you will enter the Kingdom. Instead, the church established in Jesus’ name to serve those on the margins has been an historical agent of colonization, racial prejudice, and environmental destruction, in Hawaii, and in Indigenous communities all over the world. Empire has colonized the church. Empire has turned the church into an instrument of colonization.

Now, lest we think it’s only churches that support empire, or that religion is the sole force for oppression and conflict, we should remember that staunchly atheist Russia colonized many other countries during the Soviet era. Ask Ukrainians about the Holodomor, a genocide perpetrated during the Stalin era, or ask Tibetan exiles about China. If you could somehow remove everyone’s religion bone, the justifications for colonization would change, but they would still be there. It is sadly a part of the human condition to exert dominance over others, to bend them to what we think is best for them. Empire doesn't need religion to colonize.

But it is also clear that, while churches in imperialist countries should have vigorously denounced colonization, they supported it instead, with enthusiasm. The church identifies itself foremost with the oppressed and the marginalized, and yet it’s a terrible irony that the church has disenfranchised, or helped to disenfranchise, Indigenous peoples all around the world. Malcolm X criticized the church for being so intertwined with the dominant culture that it couldn’t confront racism. Is it the same way with Indigenous peoples’ rights? Are we doomed to always conquer and colonize? Is there hope for us?


1. Indigenous peoples have the right to the dignity and diversity of their
cultures, traditions, histories and aspirations which shall be appropriately reflected
in education and public information.
Article 15 part 1, Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples


Native Americans often speak of transformation in their myths. The Anglican Indigenous Network has spoken several times of its calling to transform the life of the church. They believe that “God is leading the Church to a turning point in its history and that the full partnership of Indigenous peoples is essential.” Indigenous peoples in the Network have pledged to contribute their “vision and gift to transform the life of the Anglican community.”

Thousands of years ago in Israel, there was a tribe that derived its identity from its land, and that maintained a unique identity, heritage and history. That tribe was subject to military conquest, colonization, economic exploitation, and cultural destruction by many conquerors over the centuries, and at last by the Roman Empire. Jesus is a member of this tribe. Jesus is Indigenous.

And I think Jesus is waiting to transform His church. At our baptisms, we are asked, “Will you seek and serve Christ in every person, loving your neighbor as yourself?” We are not asked to run around bringing Jesus to others, because we do not have Jesus. Rather, we are called to go to others, to serve the Christ that is in them.

If there is hope for the church, if we are to advance the Kingdom of God, rather than the kingdoms of this world, then we must help lead this nation and the world away from empire and towards freedom. Can you imagine a church, country, a world that has renounced empire and colonization? We can start by acknowledging the needs, rights and the voices of Indigenous peoples in our midst and around the world. We can start by letting Jesus transform, redeem, and decolonize us.

The rights recognized herein constitute the minimum standards for the
survival, dignity and well-being of the indigenous peoples of the world.
Article 43, Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples


Modern reformulation of the Apostles' Creed from a Latin, modern perspective:
I believe and I live in God the Just One, the Liberator,
who created the world and my neighbor,
and in Christ of Nazareth, his only son,
and my only head,
who was born of a woman like my mother,
suffered under the oppressor's might,
was despised, marginalized, and crucified.

He descended upon the mechanisms of power,
staged a coup d'état,
and is in command, together with God the Just One, the Liberator,
And soon, when everything is under control,
he will pass judgement on rich, poor, and indifferent.

I believe in the church, which lives in the world and for it,
in liberation from alienation,
in the equality of human being,
in the Prince of Peace,
and in the new life dawning on the horizon of history.

Tuesday, November 27, 2007

Harvey Milk


No one has greater love than this, to lay down one’s life for one’s friends. - John 15:13 (NRSV)

From Robert Lentz:
Harvey Milk was the first openly gay person to be elected to high public office in the U.S. He was not a professional politician, but ran for City Supervisor in San Francisco because he felt ordinary people were being pushed aside there by monied interests. "It takes no money to respect the individual," he said. "The people are more important than words." As supervisor he fought consistently for the rights of all of those without a voice. These people included blue-collar workers, the elderly, racial minorities, and gay men and women.

The day of his election, Harvey tape-recorded his last testament, in which he acknowledged that he would most probably die violently. The last words of that message were "You gotta give them hope."


Do you know what it's like for lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender people to have one of their own numbered among the saints?

Harvey Milk is a martyr to the LGBT community, and Harvey Milk School in New York is named after him. He was Jewish, and I'm not aware that he was particularly religious. He's not on the Episcopal Church's calendar of Lesser Feasts and Fasts. However, he's a saint, and I'm going to prove it.

He came to be known as the Mayor of Castro Street; the Castro is a prominent gay neighborhood in San Francisco. It didn't used to be that way, having been Scandinavian from 1910-1920, and then Irish working class from 1930-1960. In 1975, Harvey opened a camera store, and began a life as a gay activist.

"We must destroy the myths once and for all. We must continue to speak out and most importantly every gay person must come out. As difficult as it is, you must tell your family, you must tell your relatives, you must tell your friends, you must tell your neighbors, you must tell the people you work with, you must tell the people in the stores you shop in, and once they realize that we are indeed their children and that we are indeed everywhere, every myth, every lie, every innuendo will be destroyed once and for all. And once you do you will feel so much better."


I find it interesting, by the way, that the LGBT community in the US has co-opted the term "queer" to refer to themselves. "Queer" used to be an insult. Many older LGBT folk - and some of the younger ones - I know are still uncomfortable with it.

In contrast, gays in Asia, specifically Taiwan, Hong Kong, and parts of mainland China, co-opted the term "Tong Zhi". Tong Zhi is Mandarin for "comrade", as in Comrade so-and-so. It is a polite salutation, rather than an insult. If anyone asks to illustrate how Asians think differently from Westerners, I sometimes give this as an example.

However, there's a time and a place for everything. There's a time to fit in. There's also a time to confront.

In Harvey's time, the police, the psychologists, and the priests were the main enemies of the LGBT community. Police made sting operations and arbitrary arrests. Psychologists propagated theories of impaired sexual development. Priests called homosexuality an abomination. Harvey confronted them.

Of course, he did not personally confront them with violence. For the most part, violence against the police would have been a bad idea, although Stonewall, where gays, lesbians and crossdressers fought back against the police at a raid and taunted them. This was before Harvey's time.

Harvey instead confronted his adversaries in the public square, in politics. People said he was mad to run for public office as an "avowed homosexual." He did anyway. Eventually, he became city supervisor of San Francisco. Once there, though, he acted as a comrade as well as a confronter.

"Our cities must not be abandoned. They’re worth fighting for, not just by those who live in them, but by industry, commerce, unions, everyone. What we need is a neighborhood where people can walk to work, raise their kids, enjoy life. That simple."


His time in office was sadly short. Late in 1978, the conservative board member Dan White resigned from his post. He was a vociferous opponent of George Moscone, the liberal mayor. However, he apparently changed his mind, and asked Moscone to reinstate him. Moscone, under pressure from other liberals on the board, refused him.

On November 27, 1978, White came to City Hall and demanded to speak to Moscone. Moscone refused him. White had crawled in through a window to avoid the metal detector, because he was carrying his policeman's service revolver and ten extra rounds. He shot Moscone, and then he went to Harvey's office. He confronted Harvey angrily, and shot him five times.

That night 40,000 people, men and women, old and young, gay and straight, kept candlelight vigil outside City Hall. A recording that Harvey made was played:

"This is to be played only in the event of my death by assassination.

I realize that a person who stands for what I stand for, an activist, a gay activist, becomes a target or a potential target for somebody who is insecure, terrified, afraid, or very disturbed themselves.

Knowing that I could be assassinated at any moment or any time, I feel that it's important that some people know my thoughts.

I stood for more than just a candidate. I have never considered myself a candidate. I have always considered myself part of the movement, part of the candidacy. I wish I had to explain everything I did. Almost everything was done in the eyes of the gay movement."


He also said, "If a bullet should enter my brain, let that bullet destroy every closet door."

"...Gay brothers and sisters,...You must come out. Come out...to your parents...I know that it is hard and will hurt them but think about how they will hurt you in the voting booth! Come out to your relatives...come out to your friends...if indeed they are your friends. Come out to your neighbors...to your fellow workers...to the people who work where you eat and shop...come out only to the people you know, and who know you. Not to anyone else. But once and for all, break down the myths, destroy the lies and distortions. For your sake. For their sake. For the sake of the youngsters who are becoming scared by the votes from Dade to Eugene."


Many LGBT people I know have been colonized by the church in some way. To colonize a country means to come and settle among and establish political control over the indigenous people of an area. To colonize a people means to discredit their worldview and their epistemology (way of knowing things), and to establish a foreign one. Many LGBT people have been colonized by religion.

So, many of them are in the closet to themselves and/or to their religious communities. They put up with abuse to stay in the good graces of a God they think despises them for their sexual orientations or gender identities. Many have left and would rather die than return. Perhaps Harvey was one of the latter.

And yet, I believe Harvey has something to teach Christians about the Resurrection. There's no evidence that he believed in God. And yet, he was not afraid to lay down his life for his friends. He knew he was likely going to be killed at some point - he premeditated his tape recording, just as Dan White arguably premeditated his murder. He went willingly. He was not a Christian, and yet his actions were those of one who believes in the Resurrection. As a universalist Christian, I believe that the Resurrection is for all people, everywhere.

Whether Harvey knew it or not, he was serving Jesus Christ, foreshadowing Christ's actions. Harvey was paving the way for LGBT people to come out in political life. Lentz' icon shows Harvey Milk as a servant of God, paving the way for LGBT people to come out in religious life.

But through Harvey, Jesus is decolonizing the LGBT community. To decolonize a country means to withdraw from a colony, leaving it independent. To decolonize a people means to cease to poison their hearts and minds and souls against themselves. Jesus doesn't set us free from homosexuality. Jesus sets LGBT people and the church free from homophobia and transphobia. Jesus decolonizes, and sometimes he uses servants who do not know Him to do so.

Monday, November 26, 2007

Sojourner Truth


I included a collection of diverse names of people who worked and some who gave their lives in the cause of civil justice an freedom. The names are placed behind the image of Sojourner Truth. The bottom section of the paining is mad e up of a repeated phrase from the famous speech she gave in 1851 at a women's rights convention in Akron, Ohio. I used symbols to convey a sense of ancestral histories and cultural perspectives.
James Watkins, Kalamazoo, Michigan
Bachelor of Fine Arts, Western Michigan University


Do you know what it's like for people of color to have one of their own numbered among the saints?

One of the major themes in the Bible is that God liberates. God brings the Israelites out of slavery in Egypt. Repeatedly, God sets the Israelites free from foreign slavery. They turn repeatedly to other gods, but they are finally willing and able to worship God alone.

However, people of color, and particularly indigenous peoples, will tell you that being physically free is only part of the problem. I told you earlier this year about Harriet Tubman, a conductor of the Underground Railroad, who always had to bring a gun along to shoot any of the escaping slaves who wanted to return to their masters. Sure, many slaves did a simple economic calculation and decided that returning and being punished was a bit better than being caught, tortured, and killed.

But it's more than that: slavery blights the mind and soul as well as the body. There are large parts of us that want to remain slaves. Additionally, religious establishments over time have manipulated images of God to justify the status quo of oppression. When the Spaniards came to Mexico and Latin America, for example, they conquered the native peoples, and justified it through false interpretations of the Gospel.

For example, Saúl Trinidad and Juan Stam, writing in Faces of Jesus: Latin American Christologies, outline a few depictions of Christ in Latin America that are defective, and that are intentionally or unintentionally used as the "opiate of the people," to keep people from challenging oppressive social conditions. There is the Santa Claus Christ, the dispenser of gifts. Accept Christ, and you get gifts, such as healing at a service. There are some Evangelicals who preach a gospel of prosperity - accept the Gospel and God will reward you financially. Or the magic potion Christ, the Christ who miraculously cures problems, as in this sermon quoted in the book:

Christ seeks to enter into the human heart, says the evangelist. When Jesus enters a sinner, there is direct contact with God. Jesus takes over that person's interor life, and he or she receives the supernatural power to conquer temptation ... God provides for your needs ... Are you sick? Sick with sin, sick from nerves, sick from anything? Then know this, that God has prepared for you a perfect heaven, a place of peace, love, happiness, and justice.


Another, and slightly related, false image is the passport Christ, where acceptance of Christ is a "lottery ticket" to escape to heaven from earth. Also linked to this is the asocial Christ, the dualistic Christ who demands withdrawal from the world. Certainly, conservative American Evangelicals also preach this sort of Christ.

Well, Jesus does give. But Christ doesn't give trivialities. And Christ also demands: service, sacrifice, discipleship. Liberation from material and physical deprivation is important, but it must come alongside spiritual liberation.

Sojourner Truth's story is one of spiritual liberation. Like Harriet, she was born a slave, named Isabella Baumfree. A year before New York mandated emancipation, her owner, John Dumont, promised her freedom. However, he was a harsh and cruel man, and he reneged, claiming that a hand injury made her less productive.

She spun him 100 pounds of wool to fulfill her sense of obligation. And then, she escaped with her infant daughter Sophia. She left behind Thomas, the man Dumont forced her to marry, and her other children Peter, James and Elizabeth, who were bounds as servants until they were 20.

She later met Isaac and Maria Van Wagener, a Quaker family. They took her in, and bought her services from Dumont for $20. She lived with them until New York's Emancipation Act took force, and had a life-changing religious experience that made her a devout Christian. Public Broadcasting Service, an American public media service, reports that she was swept up in the Second Great Awakening, a Protestant evangelical movement that emphasized living simply and following the Holy Spirit.

In 1827, newly-free Isabella considered returning to the Dumont farm to attend Pinkster, a celebration of New York slaves. She was saved from joining her ex-master by a frightening vision of God, followed by the calming presence of an intercessor, whom Isabella recognized as Jesus. With Jesus as her soul-protecting fortress, Isabella gained the power to rise above the battlements of fear.


She did not go back. There likely are slaves who escaped, and decided out of fear to return to their masters. Do you know what St. Martin de Porres, a half African saint and healer said when his priory was in debt? "I am only a poor mulatto. Sell me. I am the property of the order. Sell me."Parallel to that, people who have been colonized in modern times, like people in the Global South, often revisit the patterns of oppression they have been subject to upon minorities in their own cultures - a modern equivalent of returning to one's master. But Isabella did not go back. God had decolonized her.

In 1839, her son, Peter, took on a job on a whaling ship. From 1840 to 1841, she received 3 letters from him, although in his last letter he claimed he had sent 5. When the ship returned to port in 1842, Peter wasn't on board, and she never heard from him again.

On June 1, 1843, she changed her name from Isabella Baumfree to Sojourner Truth. And then, she left the Van Wagenens to preach about abolition. And, by the way, she only spoke Dutch until she escaped, and English was a late-acquired second language. And yet, she had the confidence to speak before hundreds of people.

During the Civil War, Sojourner recruited Blacks for the Union Army. In 1864, she met President Abraham Lincoln. In 1865, she rode the streetcars in Washington to help force their desegregation - shades of Rosa Parks.

Truth died on November 26, 1883, at her home in Battle Creek, Michigan. Her remains were buried there at Oak Hill Cemetery beside other family members. Her last words were "Be a follower of the Lord Jesus."

My brothers and sisters, Jesus wants God's kingdom to come about here, on earth. But that can't happen if we oppress one another. And make no mistake, oppression can easily extend beyond physical slavery. Oppression can take the form of empire. Economic and cultural domination can erode a culture's sense of self. That can cause a sense of threat that leads to authoritarianism. Look at Nazi Germany. The Allies exacted punitive reparations after WWI. The Nazis escalated antisemitism to genocide, built a war machine, and started conquering neighboring countries.

Paul, in his letter to Philemon, calls him to receive his runaway slave Onesimus. The Bible on numerous occasions fails to condemn slavery ... as Whites did in Sojourner's time. Sojourner could have gone back to her master. Today, we see formerly colonized countries replicating the patterns of oppression, like sexism, classism and homophobia, that they learned from their colonial masters. That is true colonialism.

But colonialism meets its match in Jesus, because Jesus decolonizes. Jesus decolonizes! Some Christians use Jesus to escape from this world, thinking that heaven will be better. But that way, empire wins. In contrast, empire could never destroy Sojourner Truth's soul. Jesus led her out of colonization and into freedom! And empowered by Christ she went to free others. Sojourner Truth shows for people of color all around the world, a vision of Jesus decolonized, and a vision of Jesus decolonizing.

Women in the Stone Church Meet Sojourner Truth
(Recollections of "And Ain't I a Woman?" speech, Old Stone Church, Akron, Ohio, May 1851)

Patricia Flower Vermillion is Writer in Residence for the Artists in Education program of the Virginia 11 Commission for the Arts. Her poetry has appeared in Theology Today, The Writer, Them a, Poet, and other journals. This poem was published in Theology Today Vol 53 No 1, 1996

Chosen, we are called
to champion uneducated women in chains.
Our horse hair underskirts keep silk
from touching the ground. Belgian lace
collars and bonnets are copied carefully
from Godey's Ladies Book; uniformly
steamed and pressed.

In the Old Stone Church, surrounded by men
who think we are deceived by the serpent
only our corsets keep us from collapsing. Suddenly, church doors open and bold breezes
process down aisles with a black broom woman.
Her unbleached cotton skirt stirs up twigs
and laughter. Queen of scarecrows, she pushes
chairs to a corner then extends herself
while ministers tell us, women-real women
must be cared for and helped into carriages.
When the dark broom rises
mill workers lock arms at elbows
to form whistling walls. She looks up
and sweeps silence across pews-preaches
prophesies, picks walls apart
with sharp straw words. In the end
ministers and mill hands applaud
and stones shout.

Scratched by horse hair skirts
light headed, laced tight
we are culture's captives
while Sojourner Truth
stands seventy two inches, head-to-toe free.

Sunday, November 25, 2007

Dorothy Day



Women have had their own numbered as saints for some time now, only they have too often been saints of what I feel is excessive piety. However, Dorothy Day is a saint by activism, and she stands as the equal of any man among the saints.

"What we do is very little. But it is like the little boy with a few loaves and fishes. Christ took that little and increased it. He will do the rest. What we do is so little we may seem to be constantly failing. But so did He fail. He met with apparent failure on the Cross. But unless the seed fall into the earth and die, there is no harvest. And why must we see results? Our work is to sow. Another generation will be reaping the harvest."
—Dorothy Day


Dorothy Day has been declared a Servant of God, the first step to sainthood. Her actual feast day to be is November 29, but I'm moving her up to today to fit in better with the articles I have for this week. Dorothy Day and Peter Maurin co-founded the Catholic Worker movement, and published a newsletter. That newsletter continues to this day. Peter Maurin, a French, working-class, Catholic activist, outlined the beliefs of Catholic Workers in a brief reproduced below.

1. The Catholic Worker believes
in the gentle personalism
of traditional Catholicism.
2. The Catholic Worker believes
in the personal obligation
of looking after
the needs of our brother.
3. The Catholic Worker believes
in the daily practice
of the Works of Mercy.
4. The Catholic Worker believes
in Houses of Hospitality
for the immediate relief
of those who are in need.
5. The Catholic Worker believes
in the establishment
of Farming Communes
where each one works
according to his ability
and gets according to his need.
6. The Catholic Worker believes
in creating a new society
within the shell of the old
with the philosophy of the new,
which is not a new philosophy
but a very old philosophy,
a philosophy so old
that it looks like new.

Day and Maurin were anarchists. Catholic Worker houses were small, non-hierarchical communities. They showed hospitality to all on the margins of society, including undocumented immigrants. Dorothy later worked with Cesar Chavez and the farm workers' movement. As Dorothy said, "The only way to live in any true security is to live so close to the bottom that when you fall you do not have far to drop, you do not have much to lose."

Trinity Stores' site has an elaboration on Dorothy's life, summarized from the book Praying with Dorothy Day by James Allaire and Rosemary Broughton. They state that at the time of the founding of the Catholic Worker newsletter, in 1933, Catholics had been "criticized for a lack of social and political morality." The teachings and actions of the church were not socially conscious. An emphasis on excessive personal piety has long been one of my main criticisms of Roman Catholicism and conservative Evangelicism.

But the Catholic Worker movement instead turns personal piety into a tool for social activism.

We believe this needed personal and social transformation should be pursued by the means Jesus revealed in His sacrificial love. With Christ as our Exemplar, by prayer and communion with His Body and Blood, we strive for practices of

--Nonviolence. "Blessed are the peacemakers, for they shall be called children of God." (Matt. 5:9) Only through nonviolent action can a personalist revolution come about, one in which one evil will not be replaced simply by another. Thus, we oppose the deliberate taking of human life for any reason, and see every oppression as blasphemy. Jesus taught us to take suffering upon ourselves rather than inflict it upon others, and He calls us to fight against violence with the spiritual weapons of prayer, fasting and noncooperation with evil. Refusal to pay taxes for war, to register for conscription, to comply with any unjust legislation; participation in nonviolent strikes and boycotts, protests or vigils; withdrawal of support for dominant systems, corporate funding or usurious practices are all excellent means to establish peace.

--The works of mercy (as found in Matt. 25:31-46) are at the heart of the Gospel and they are clear mandates for our response to "the least of our brothers and sisters." Houses of hospitality are centers for learning to do the acts of love, so that the poor can receive what is, in justice, theirs, the second coat in our closet, the spare room in our home, a place at our table. Anything beyond what we immediately need belongs to those who go without.

--Manual labor, in a society that rejects it as undignified and inferior. "Besides inducing cooperation, besides overcoming barriers and establishing the spirit of sister and brotherhood (besides just getting things done), manual labor enables us to use our bodies as well as our hands, our minds." (Dorothy Day) The Benedictine motto Ora et Labora reminds us that the work of human hands is a gift for the edification of the world and the glory of God.

--Voluntary poverty. "The mystery of poverty is that by sharing in it, making ourselves poor in giving to others, we increase our knowledge and belief in love." (Dorothy Day) By embracing voluntary poverty, that is, by casting our lot freely with those whose impoverishment is not a choice, we would ask for the grace to abandon ourselves to the love of God. It would put us on the path to incarnate the Church's "preferential option for the poor."


My sisters and brothers, Dorothy Day is calling everyone who seeks to bring about God's kingdom. The United States proclaims that in the political realm, the Church and State are separate. However, it has failed to separate the State and Business. Those two are not separate, and our State too often operates for the benefit of Business.

Frankly, I am very different from Dorothy Day. I am a capitalist and I believe in the free market for some things, perhaps many things. And yet, her example reminds me that the Church is called to be at the service of the "least of these." At God's table, the poor will sit first. The rich will only get a seat if they relinquish their power and humble themselves (Jesus, I might remind you, instead calls on us to sell all we have and give to the poor).

But too often, the Church has failed to condemn both State and Business when they violate human rights, despoil the environment, and propagate bigotry. The Church has forgotten that the early Christians drew on all those at the margins of society. This is a Church that lives on the margins!

And yet, the Church has been colonized, and it has allowed itself to be an agent of colonialism. Look at how often Christian nations have gone on crusades of empire, at how we today despoil the environment to maintain our lifestyles, at how we abuse and exploit immigrants, at how we treat people of color. A colonized Church cannot truly serve God.

Can the Church be decolonized? Can the Church become an agent of decolonization? Dorothy Day calls us back to our roots, to live with and serve those on the margins. Dorothy Day presents with a vision ... a vision of a Church decolonized.

O God, you made us all unique;
one pattern for each life you found.
Where falling short of your design
you see us, free us
till by love we're bound.

O Christ, you summon into life
our timid faith, our hidden skill.
Where trust or talent are untried,
there tend us. Send us
grace to know your will.

O Holy Spirit, breath of life,
our noblest visions you inspire.
Where hearts are cold or minds are dull,
there shake us. Make us
flames of heaven's fire.

To God, in whom we live and move,
we vow our love and loyalty;
and here ascribe all honour, power
and glory, glory
now and endlessly.

John Bell, Iona Community

Tuesday, September 18, 2007

Dag Hamarskjöld

Heavenly Father, who have taught us that the peacemakers shall be called the children of God: Grant that, like your servant Dag Hamarskjöld, we may always seek to live at peace with our neighbors, and to reconcile those living in strife and enmity; so that in this way we may follow in the footsteps of your beloved Son Jesus Christ our Lord; who lives and reigns with you and the Holy Spirit, one God, now and for ever. Amen.

Saturday, September 01, 2007

Labor Day and Cesar Chavez




Cesar Chavez died on April 23, 1993. I had forgotten to put his icon up on that day, but it turns out that Labor Day is also very appropriate for this tireless advocate of labor rights. Robert Lentz, who drew this icon, describes him perfectly.

Cesar Chavez, champion of the poor, saw his family’s home and small farm seized by creditors when he was only 10. He spent his youth as a migrant worker, traveling with his family wherever there were crops to harvest. They shared what little they had with those who had less.

Work in the fields meant long hours of backbreaking tasks and exposure to dangerous pesticides, for half the wages other workers in the United States could expect. Workers had no rights and lived at the mercy of employers. This experience of helplessness and poverty engendered in Cesar a profound thirst for justice. From 1952 until his death, he worked ceaselessly to improve the lot of his people.

After ten years of working in voter registration drives and in challenging police and immigration abuse, he turned his attention to the struggle for justice for migrant workers. Using non-violent tactics and sustained by the deep spirituality of his Catholic Mexican roots, he led the United Farm Workers through seemingly impossible situations. Agribusiness sometimes responded with violence. Several union members were killed. Even the Teamsters tried to sabotage what gains his union made. In spite of all odds, he made the plight of migrants known to the rest of the nation, giving a voice to those who had been forgotten.

Always a poor man, Cesar sometimes had to ask for food for his wife and children from the very workers he was trying to organize. He died on April 23, away from home on union business, after an eight-day water-only fast. An estimated 35 thousand people formed his three-mile-long funeral procession. He was buried as a poor man in a simple pine box. He remains in our midst, however, as a patron of all the poor, but especially of immigrant minorities who suffer solely because they will not watch their families starve. In this icon he carries the Constitution of the United States, for whose guarantees he fought, on behalf of all the oppressed.


The Cesar Chavez Foundation describes one of his struggles.

Since 1975, the UFW won most of the union elections in which it participated. Despite the farm labor board's bureaucratic delays, farm workers made progress. By the early 1980's farm workers numbered in the tens of thousands were working under UFW contracts enjoying higher pay, family health coverage, pension benefits and other contract protections.

Then, in 1982, with more than $1 million in grower campaign donations, Republican George Deukmejian was elected Governor of California. Most objective observers agree that under Deukmejian, the farm labor board ceased to enforce the law. In 1984, Cesar called for another grape boycott. In July and August 1988, he conducted a 36 day "Fast for Life" to protest the pesticide poisoning of grape workers and their children. Cesar lived with his family since 1970 at La Paz, in Keene, California, the union's headquarters in Kern County's Tehachapi Mountains, east of Bakersfield,. Like other UFW officers and staff, he received subsistence pay that didn't top $5,000 a year.


Gross labor violations continue today in blue collar occupations, even in the US. Labor and human rights violations occur abroad, where we outsource our production. Even in white collar occupations, questionable labor practices continue. For example, despite the fact that previous Popes have endorsed unions, and the fact that Chavez (and a number of other famous labor rights activists, like Dorothy Day and Mother Jones) was Catholic, the Church has done such things as refuse teachers the right to organize. In addition, a lot of Catholic hospitals take measures to prevent unionization.

Is there a better way?

Cingular, now AT&T, declared neutrality on unions, and did not interfere in union activities.

"Management didn’t pressure us or try to interfere. Our union campaign was positive and without conflict. We didn’t attack the company and they didn’t attack us. We were focused on improving our jobs and making Cingular a better place to work."
Larry Barrett, wireless tech


Although Harley Davidson recently had a strike, its good union relations have saved the company in the past:

Continuous improvement demands involvement from employees. Management's dilemma was how to align employee motivation with company goals. In Harley-Davidson's case, all employees take part in a gain-sharing program and are paid cash incentives for attaining and maintaining quality, profitability, and product delivery goals. In 1995, more than 2,000 of Harley's 4,694 employees took training and education programs from the Harley-Davidson Learning Center. These courses helped the company to be more competitive and to foster employees' personal growth and development. Extensive team-building has taken place at all levels of the company, including team-building for union leaders, negotiation committees, and stewards. Open communication, at all levels, is used as a major key to achieving teamwork and employee participation. For example, engineers are located right in the plant, within walking distance of machine operators. The practice of open communication is also represented in the relationship between top management and the union.

Harley Davidson has an untypical relationship with the union. Continuous improvement techniques could have been stopped if the company did not have a good relationship with the union. The union viewed management as a partner instead of an adversary. Management's good-faith dealing's with the union was a factor in this special relationship. Harley-Davidson has a history of in-sourcing; it tries to bring as much work as possible into the plant to forestall any layoffs. The union has considerable control over what kind of work is outsourced to other companies. So the union is able to create a "job security" by choosing the work that is done in-house. Bob Klebar, the president of the union stated, "When times are good, we´d outsource it. But if things get tougher, we´d look at those projects and maybe bring them in-house to keep the employment" (Filipczak 41). He also mentioned that "instead of focusing on what we think we have a right to, his people work closely with the production department, and everyone concentrates on the final customer. It really binds us together and makes us go in the right direction" (Filipczak 41). Teerlink, Harley-Davidson´s CEO, said that total employee involvement (EI) cannot exist until management and labor can agree that they have a mutual goal: the long-term success of the company (Reid 173). In this joint process, joint union-management study groups identify issues or problems and then research all possible solutions.


United Parcel Service has high levels of unionization, and high employee stock ownership. Employees own a class of stock that gives them ten times the voting power of the regular shares, so they have great say in how the company is run, and also strong incentive to run it well. I should also note that while the CEO of Whole Foods, John Mackey, is rabidly anti-union, its employees also have high levels of stock ownership, which contributes to an empowered, productive culture.

Monday, August 27, 2007

Hélder Câmara, died 1999


Hélder Câmara, 1909-1999

"When I give food to the poor, they call me a saint. When I ask why the poor have no food, they call me a Communist."






His friends called him Dom Helder. His enemies called him the Red Bishop. Even today, the Red specter still haunts our political discourse. For example, if you talk about universal healthcare in the US, some might invoke the specter of "socialized medicine".

His uncompromising commitment to the church of the poor gave us courage to challenge our own culture of middle-class religion. His courage in the face of Brazil’s military regime inspired us to take on the militarism of our own country. And his firm commitment to nonviolence, particularly his political analysis of the "spiral of violence," grounded us in a theory and practice of revolutionary struggle without arms.

Ched Meyers, writing for Sojourners magazine in 1999.


When he died in 1999, the National Catholic Reporter called him a "lover of the poor."

Rosemary Radford Ruether, also a Sojourners writer, tells us that many Latin American bishops came in conservative, and were radicalized by the extreme poverty, violence and suffering. The Roman church has, to its disgrace, silenced many liberation theologians. Câmara focused his seminary on grassroots ministry to the poor, only to see that work and others undone by his right-wing successor.

In the language of Latin Americans who remember the martyrs with the cry "presente!" Helder Câmara, although dead, still lives. He rises again in our remembrance of him to continue to inspire followers.

—Rosemary Radford Ruether


But Pope John XXIII, the guy who started Vatican II, said,

"We are not on earth to guard a museum, but to cultivate a flourishing garden of life."


Professor Jeanette Rodriguez put it a bit differently, "God is always pregnant." Gardens flourish, mothers give birth ... God, in other words, is always at work. God cannot be stopped. Câmara knew that. He was content.

"The Spirit of God breaths life into the Abrahamic minorities that already exist in the womb of all races, all religious, all countries and all human groups. Whoever hopes against hope, like Abraham, and decides to work, even sacrifice for a more just and humane world, belongs to these Abrahamic minorities."



Please pray for:

The poor.

All people who seek to advance God's agenda of liberation.

All the above, especially Roman Catholics, who are persecuted by church or secular hierarchies.

The rich, that our ignorance and selfishness may come to an end.